1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. New York County Supreme Courts
  5. Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mou

Case Last Refreshed: 11 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor, filed a(n) Malpractice - Torts case represented by Silver, Perry David, against Ankit R Shah Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Erin P Patton Md, (total of 16) See All represented by Dimartino, Theresa Maria, Mcnaboe, John Peter, Monteith, Michael Scott, Whalen Reinle, Christina Antonia, in the jurisdiction of New York County. This case was filed in New York County Superior Courts New York County Supreme Court with George J. Silver presiding.

Case Details for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor v. Ankit R Shah Md , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)

Judge

George J. Silver

pdf Get Judge Analytics Report

Filing Date

November 05, 2014

Category

Medical Malpractice

Last Refreshed

August 01, 2023

Practice Area

Torts

Filing Location

New York County, NY

Matter Type

Malpractice

Filing Court House

New York County Supreme Court

Case Outcome Type

Disposed

Case Cycle Time

412 days

Parties for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor v. Ankit R Shah Md , et al.

Plaintiffs

Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Silver, Perry David

Defendants

Ankit R Shah Md

Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc

Christina K Nadar Md

Continuum Health Partners, Inc.

Erin P Patton Md

Ilan Shapira Md

James F Winchester Md

Karleung Siu Md

Mai K Kaga Md

Michael Felsen Md

Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System

Nikki D Tang Md

Nikolas B Harbord Md

Patrice Sonara Md

Patricia Dharapek Md

Richard Armerling Md

Attorneys for Defendants

Dimartino, Theresa Maria

Mcnaboe, John Peter

Monteith, Michael Scott

Whalen Reinle, Christina Antonia

Other Parties

Beth Israel Medical Center (Non Party)

Dr. Michael Felsen, Dr. Mai Kada, Dr. James Winchester, Dr. Christine Nadar & Dr. Patricia Dharapek (Non Party)

Case Documents for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor v. Ankit R Shah Md , et al.

for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION

Date: October 20, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION (Motion #001)

Date: December 22, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

ANSWER

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)

Date: December 04, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

ANSWER

Date: March 19, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

ANSWER

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

ANSWER

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

ANSWER

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

SUMMONS + COMPLAINT

Date: November 05, 2014
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

ANSWER

Date: April 08, 2015
for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor V. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center Of The Mount Sinai Health System, Continuum Health Partners, Inc., Ilan Shapira Md, Michael Felsen Md, Karleung Siu Md, Mai K Kaga Md, James F Winchester Md, Erin P Patton Md, Nikki D Tang Md, Nikolas B Harbord Md, Richard Armerling Md, Avantus Renal Therapy New York Llc, Christina K Nadar Md, Ankit R Shah Md, Patrice Sonara Md, Patricia Dharapek Md

NOTICE OF MOTION (Motion #001)

Date: November 06, 2015

Case Events for Paul Mindolovitch As Proposed Administrator Of The Estate Of Monica Mindolovitch And Individually And As Parent And Natural Guardian Of Robert Mindolovitch, A Minor And Simone Mindolovitch, A Minor v. Ankit R Shah Md , et al.

Date Type Description
December 22, 2015 Docket Event DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION (Motion #001)
View Document
December 15, 2015 Hearing FULLY SUBMITTED (Motion #001)
E-FILING SUBMISSIONS CALENDAR
STIP

Judge: SILVER, GEORGE J.
December 04, 2015 Docket Event STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
View Document
December 01, 2015 Motion DISMISS ACTION (Motion #001)
Decided: 12/17/2015CASE DISPOSED Before Justice: SILVER, GEORGE J.
Answer demanded: No

Judge: SILVER, GEORGE J.
December 01, 2015 Hearing ADJOURNED (Motion #001)
E-FILING SUBMISSIONS CALENDAR
MOVANT

Judge: LOBIS, JOAN B.
November 16, 2015 Docket Event AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Aff of Service - Motion to Dismiss
November 16, 2015 Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - D
Good Faith letter dated 8/10/2015
November 16, 2015 Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - C
Demand for Bill of Particulars & various demands
November 16, 2015 Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - B
Answer of Avantus Renal Therapy
November 16, 2015 Docket Event EXHIBIT(S) - A
Summons & Complaint dated 11/5/14
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.