Preview
Filing # 181858756 E-Filed 09/14/2023 05:14:39 PM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT,
IN AND FOR OSCEOLA COUNTY, FLORIDA
XIAO SHENG YUE,
Plaintiff,
CASE NO.: 2020-CA-1106AN
v.
CYNTHIA M. FOERSTER AND
CHAPP, INC.,
Defendants.
______________________________/
DEFENDANTS, CYNTHIA M. FOERSTER AND CHAPP, INC.’S, AMENDED WITNESS
AND EXHIBIT LIST
COME NOW, Defendants, CYNTHIA M. FOERSTER and CHAPP, INC., by and through
their undersigned counsel, and files this their Witness and Exhibit List and notifies the Court of its
intent to possibly utilize the below witnesses at trial:
1. Cynthia M. Foerster
Chapp, Inc.
c/o Jorge Santeiro, Esq.
Santeiro & Garrison
6300 University Parkway, Suite 101
Sarasota, FL 34240
2. Chapp, Inc.
Corporate Representative
c/o Jorge Santeiro, Esq.
Santeiro & Garrison
6300 University Parkway, Suite 101
Sarasota, FL 34240
3. Xiao Sheng Yue
c/o Manuel F. Stefan, Esq.
Morgan and Morgan, P.A.
4495 S. Semoran Blvd.
Orlando, FL 32822
1
4. Michael Taylor, EMT Paramedic and/or EMS crew members
Kissimmee Fire Department
P.O. Box 917456
Orlando, FL 32891
5. Javier E. Rosario, M.D.
700 W. Oak St.
Kissimmee, FL 34741
6. Any and all witnesses listed in notices of production from non-parties.
7. Any and all witnesses listed in answers to interrogatories.
8. Any and all witnesses listed in responses to request for production.
9. Any and all witnesses deposed during the course of this lawsuit.
10. Any and all witnesses named in depositions not yet completed.
11. Any and all witnesses identified by Plaintiff, without waiving objections thereto.
12. Any and all rebuttal or impeachment witnesses.
13. Any and all custodians of records for documents, photos and videos exchanged in discovery.
14. Defendants reserve the right to supplement this Witness List as additional witnesses become
known through the process of discovery.
DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBITS
1. Defendants’ Scene Photos
2. Plaintiff’s Scene Photos
3. Surveillance Video (1.17.19 and 1.18.19)
4. Surveillance Video (10.21.20)
5. Surveillance Video (10.31.18 and 11.1.18)
6. Surveillance Video (10.5.18 and 10.7.18)
7. Surveillance Video (10.7.19)
8. Surveillance Video (2.25.20)
9. Surveillance Video (3.15.21)
10. Surveillance Video (4.24.19 and 4.29.19)
11. Surveillance Video (7.10.21)
12. Surveillance Video (8.17.21 and 8.18.21)
13. Surveillance Video (7.7.21 – 7.10.21)
14. Surveillance Stills (1.16.19 -1.18.19)
2
15. Surveillance Stills (10.21.20 – 10.26.20)
16. Surveillance Stills (10.31.18 – 11.1.18)
17. Surveillance Stills (10.5.18 – 10.7.18)
18. Surveillance Stills (10.7.19 – 10.8.19)
19. Surveillance Stills (2.19.20 – 2.25.20)
20. Surveillance Stills (3.15.21 – 3.17.21)
21. Surveillance Stills (4.24.19 -4.25.19)
22. Surveillance Stills (7.7.21 – 7.10.21)
23. Federation of State Medical Boards 9.30.21
24. Allstate Insurance Co. (1.4.23)
25. Allstate Insurance Co. (10.20.22)
26. American Strategic Insurance (2.14.23)
27. Amica Mutual Insurance (11.3.22)
28. Amica Mutual Insurance (11.29.22)
29. Amical Mutual Insurance (PIP) 6.15.21
30. Farmers Insurance Exchange 11.7.22
31. Geico Insurance 10.6.22
32. Liberty Mutual Insurance 11.29.22
33. Progressive Home Claim Records 2.7.23
34. Progressive Recorded Statement 1.22.21
35. UPC Insurance Documents
36. LOP’s Dr. Sharfman
37. 10-11-2018 L-Spine MRI
38. 11-03-20 Knee MRI
39. 2017 MVA Crash Report
40. 2017 MVA EMS Report
41. 9-27-18 C-Spine MRI
42. 9-27-18 C-Spine MRI Addendum
43. 9-27-18 L-Spine MRI Addendum
44. 9-27-18 Brain MRI
45. 9-27-18 Brain MRI Addendum
46. 9-5-17 Brain MRI
3
47. 9-5-17 C-Spine MRI
48. 9-5-17 L-Spine MRI
49. Brain & Nerve Center (Dr. Chafke) 2018 MRI
50. Dr. Sharfman 2017 MRI
51. Dr. Sharfman 2019 MRI
52. Dr. Spengler Records
53. EMS Report 9-11-18
54. ER Records ORMC 9-11-18
55. Head CT ORMC 9-11-18
56. Kissimmee Medical Well Being 2018 MRI
57. Neuro Opthamology (Lyn Sedwick, M.D.) 2019
58. Orthopaedic and Spine Medical Group, inc. 2017 Records (Part 1)
59. Orthopaedic and Spine Medical Group, inc. 2017 Records (Part 2)
60. Plaintiff’s Hospital Photos
61. Poinciana ER Records 2017
62. Prior lawsuit Complaint 2019
63. Ramirez and Poulos, MD., P.A. Records 2019
64. Those exhibits necessary for impeachment purposes.
65. Any and all exhibits listed on the Plaintiff’s Witness List and Expert Witness List.
66. Photographs and diagrams of the accident scene.
67. Photographs of the vehicles involved in the accident.
68. Medical records of the Plaintiff, including records of treatment prior and subsequent to the
accident.
69. Hospital records of the Plaintiff.
70. X-rays, MRI films, CT scans, and any other diagnostic tests and/or studies.
71. Employment records of the Plaintiff.
72. Collateral source policies and records pertaining to the Plaintiff.
73. Income tax returns of the Plaintiff.
74. Police accident report.
75. Any and all photographs, diagrams, films, and videotapes of the accident scene and/or
parties to this lawsuit.
76. Any and all exhibits listed on any previously filed Exhibit Lists in the above cause.
4
77. Clinical Practice Guidelines and Associated Publications of the United States Public Health
Service pertaining to the Plaintiffs condition.
78. Demonstrative exhibits consisting of depictions of the Plaintiff s MRI and other
radiographic and comparative studies with respect to the alleged injuries at issue in this
cause.
79. Any and all depositions filed with the Court.
80. Any and all responses to Requests for Admissions.
81. Any and all responses to Request for Production.
82. Any and all responses to Interrogatories.
83. Damage repair estimates for the vehicles involved in the subject accident.
84. Any and all medical reports relied upon by any expert to formulate the expert’s opinion or
prognosis.
85. Insurance records related to any accident(s) or incident(s) Plaintiff was involved in prior
and subsequent to the subject accident, including photos of any vehicles involved in the
accident(s) and damage repair estimates.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that, on this 14th day of September 2023, I electronically filed the
foregoing with the Clerk of the Court via the Florida Courts’ e-Filing Portal, pursuant to and in
compliance with Rule 2.516, Florida Rules of Judicial Administration, which completes service
by furnishing a true and correct copy of the foregoing via electronic mail to all counsel of record.
/s/ Jorge Santeiro_
LAW OFFICES OF SANTEIRO & GARRISON
Jorge Santeiro
FBN 66230
6300 University Parkway
Suite 101
Sarasota, FL 34240
Tel: (800) 226-3224, Ext. 1021
Primary: jsanteiro@fcci-aroup.com
Secondary: ssmith5@fcci-group.com
Secondary: legalservice@fcci-aroup.com
Attorney for Defendants
5
Preview
Filing # 181858756 E-Filed 09/14/2023 05:14:39 PM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR OSCEOLA COUNTY, FLORIDA XIAO SHENG YUE, Plaintiff, CASE NO.: 2020-CA-1106AN v. CYNTHIA M. FOERSTER AND CHAPP, INC., Defendants. ______________________________/ DEFENDANTS, CYNTHIA M. FOERSTER AND CHAPP, INC.’S, AMENDED WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST COME NOW, Defendants, CYNTHIA M. FOERSTER and CHAPP, INC., by and through their undersigned counsel, and files this their Witness and Exhibit List and notifies the Court of its intent to possibly utilize the below witnesses at trial: 1. Cynthia M. Foerster Chapp, Inc. c/o Jorge Santeiro, Esq. Santeiro & Garrison 6300 University Parkway, Suite 101 Sarasota, FL 34240 2. Chapp, Inc. Corporate Representative c/o Jorge Santeiro, Esq. Santeiro & Garrison 6300 University Parkway, Suite 101 Sarasota, FL 34240 3. Xiao Sheng Yue c/o Manuel F. Stefan, Esq. Morgan and Morgan, P.A. 4495 S. Semoran Blvd. Orlando, FL 32822 1 4. Michael Taylor, EMT Paramedic and/or EMS crew members Kissimmee Fire Department P.O. Box 917456 Orlando, FL 32891 5. Javier E. Rosario, M.D. 700 W. Oak St. Kissimmee, FL 34741 6. Any and all witnesses listed in notices of production from non-parties. 7. Any and all witnesses listed in answers to interrogatories. 8. Any and all witnesses listed in responses to request for production. 9. Any and all witnesses deposed during the course of this lawsuit. 10. Any and all witnesses named in depositions not yet completed. 11. Any and all witnesses identified by Plaintiff, without waiving objections thereto. 12. Any and all rebuttal or impeachment witnesses. 13. Any and all custodians of records for documents, photos and videos exchanged in discovery. 14. Defendants reserve the right to supplement this Witness List as additional witnesses become known through the process of discovery. DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBITS 1. Defendants’ Scene Photos 2. Plaintiff’s Scene Photos 3. Surveillance Video (1.17.19 and 1.18.19) 4. Surveillance Video (10.21.20) 5. Surveillance Video (10.31.18 and 11.1.18) 6. Surveillance Video (10.5.18 and 10.7.18) 7. Surveillance Video (10.7.19) 8. Surveillance Video (2.25.20) 9. Surveillance Video (3.15.21) 10. Surveillance Video (4.24.19 and 4.29.19) 11. Surveillance Video (7.10.21) 12. Surveillance Video (8.17.21 and 8.18.21) 13. Surveillance Video (7.7.21 – 7.10.21) 14. Surveillance Stills (1.16.19 -1.18.19) 2 15. Surveillance Stills (10.21.20 – 10.26.20) 16. Surveillance Stills (10.31.18 – 11.1.18) 17. Surveillance Stills (10.5.18 – 10.7.18) 18. Surveillance Stills (10.7.19 – 10.8.19) 19. Surveillance Stills (2.19.20 – 2.25.20) 20. Surveillance Stills (3.15.21 – 3.17.21) 21. Surveillance Stills (4.24.19 -4.25.19) 22. Surveillance Stills (7.7.21 – 7.10.21) 23. Federation of State Medical Boards 9.30.21 24. Allstate Insurance Co. (1.4.23) 25. Allstate Insurance Co. (10.20.22) 26. American Strategic Insurance (2.14.23) 27. Amica Mutual Insurance (11.3.22) 28. Amica Mutual Insurance (11.29.22) 29. Amical Mutual Insurance (PIP) 6.15.21 30. Farmers Insurance Exchange 11.7.22 31. Geico Insurance 10.6.22 32. Liberty Mutual Insurance 11.29.22 33. Progressive Home Claim Records 2.7.23 34. Progressive Recorded Statement 1.22.21 35. UPC Insurance Documents 36. LOP’s Dr. Sharfman 37. 10-11-2018 L-Spine MRI 38. 11-03-20 Knee MRI 39. 2017 MVA Crash Report 40. 2017 MVA EMS Report 41. 9-27-18 C-Spine MRI 42. 9-27-18 C-Spine MRI Addendum 43. 9-27-18 L-Spine MRI Addendum 44. 9-27-18 Brain MRI 45. 9-27-18 Brain MRI Addendum 46. 9-5-17 Brain MRI 3 47. 9-5-17 C-Spine MRI 48. 9-5-17 L-Spine MRI 49. Brain & Nerve Center (Dr. Chafke) 2018 MRI 50. Dr. Sharfman 2017 MRI 51. Dr. Sharfman 2019 MRI 52. Dr. Spengler Records 53. EMS Report 9-11-18 54. ER Records ORMC 9-11-18 55. Head CT ORMC 9-11-18 56. Kissimmee Medical Well Being 2018 MRI 57. Neuro Opthamology (Lyn Sedwick, M.D.) 2019 58. Orthopaedic and Spine Medical Group, inc. 2017 Records (Part 1) 59. Orthopaedic and Spine Medical Group, inc. 2017 Records (Part 2) 60. Plaintiff’s Hospital Photos 61. Poinciana ER Records 2017 62. Prior lawsuit Complaint 2019 63. Ramirez and Poulos, MD., P.A. Records 2019 64. Those exhibits necessary for impeachment purposes. 65. Any and all exhibits listed on the Plaintiff’s Witness List and Expert Witness List. 66. Photographs and diagrams of the accident scene. 67. Photographs of the vehicles involved in the accident. 68. Medical records of the Plaintiff, including records of treatment prior and subsequent to the accident. 69. Hospital records of the Plaintiff. 70. X-rays, MRI films, CT scans, and any other diagnostic tests and/or studies. 71. Employment records of the Plaintiff. 72. Collateral source policies and records pertaining to the Plaintiff. 73. Income tax returns of the Plaintiff. 74. Police accident report. 75. Any and all photographs, diagrams, films, and videotapes of the accident scene and/or parties to this lawsuit. 76. Any and all exhibits listed on any previously filed Exhibit Lists in the above cause. 4 77. Clinical Practice Guidelines and Associated Publications of the United States Public Health Service pertaining to the Plaintiffs condition. 78. Demonstrative exhibits consisting of depictions of the Plaintiff s MRI and other radiographic and comparative studies with respect to the alleged injuries at issue in this cause. 79. Any and all depositions filed with the Court. 80. Any and all responses to Requests for Admissions. 81. Any and all responses to Request for Production. 82. Any and all responses to Interrogatories. 83. Damage repair estimates for the vehicles involved in the subject accident. 84. Any and all medical reports relied upon by any expert to formulate the expert’s opinion or prognosis. 85. Insurance records related to any accident(s) or incident(s) Plaintiff was involved in prior and subsequent to the subject accident, including photos of any vehicles involved in the accident(s) and damage repair estimates. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that, on this 14th day of September 2023, I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of the Court via the Florida Courts’ e-Filing Portal, pursuant to and in compliance with Rule 2.516, Florida Rules of Judicial Administration, which completes service by furnishing a true and correct copy of the foregoing via electronic mail to all counsel of record. /s/ Jorge Santeiro_ LAW OFFICES OF SANTEIRO & GARRISON Jorge Santeiro FBN 66230 6300 University Parkway Suite 101 Sarasota, FL 34240 Tel: (800) 226-3224, Ext. 1021 Primary: jsanteiro@fcci-aroup.com Secondary: ssmith5@fcci-group.com Secondary: legalservice@fcci-aroup.com Attorney for Defendants 5