On August 29, 2023 a
EXHIBIT(S) - D (Motion #001) - DOBs Emergency Declaration Database for the May 5, 2022 Emergency Declaration
was filed
involving a dispute between
Projjal Dutta,
and
Lisa Silversmith
A K A Lisa Fiekowsky,
The City Of New York,
for Other Real Property - Unsafe Buildings
in the District Court of New York County.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 16 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023
EXHIBIT D
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023
NYSCEF 10:58 AM
11/29/23,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023
Emergency Declaration Database
Home Declarations
Welcome Rachel ! [ Logout ]
451 Convent Avenue, Manhattan 16879
--- Submit New Status ---
Declaration Information A
Num Street Boro BIN Block Lot City Owned
451 Convent Avenue Manhattan v . 1061556 ; 2064 49
3 Landmark
Work Action to Take: DOB Emergency Declaration
Number:
OBackfill
HPD Complaint Number:
OBrace and Shore: Building
OBrace and Shore: Retaining Wall
Declaration Priority: Emergency v
GGrade and Fence Site
Erect Fence or Sidewalk Shed
Emergency Declaration Issued
ORepair Fence or Sidewalk Shed 5/5/2022 V
Date (date signed by BC):
GFull Demolition Request
General Comments:
OPartial Demolition Request
Remedy : Fully Demolish the building . Grade and
fence site.
OSeal Building
....
OOther (specify)
Attachments:
File Name A_dd
(d
ED 451 Convent Ave_.pf X
Authorization Letter 16879,pdf
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD letter
- X
7-14-22.pg
451 Convent Avenue - EXECUTE
LETTER #16879.pdf
X
451 Convent Avenue - Rescission
7-28-22.p
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD letter
X
S-19-22.pg
451 - HOLD - 8-
Convent Avenue
26-22.pH
451 Convent Avenue - 9-2-22
HOLD .p
X
mspwa-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 1/
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023
NYSCEF DOC.
11/29/23, 10:58 NO.
AM 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn
Letter 9-16-22.pdf
X
451 Convent Avenue - Hold Extn
Letter 10-26-22.pdf
X
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn
Letter - 12-07-22.pdf
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD EXTN -
X
1-13-23.pdf
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn
Letter 04-07-23.pdf
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn
Letter 07-07-2023.pdf
451 Convent Avenue - Hold Extn
Letter 08-01-23.pdf
X
451 Convent - BOLD EXTN -
Aveppe
10-11-23.pdf
451 Convent Avenue - HOLD EXTN -
11-3-23.pdf
Status History
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:11/3/2023
Hold End Date:12/3/2023
Hold to allow owner to remedy condition. Thank you.
Campbell, Denise 11/3/2023 3:42PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:10/2/2023
Hold End Date:11/2/2023
Hold to allow owner to remedy condition.
Campbell, Denise 10/11/2023 1:39PM
HPD: Other (see comments)
Hold expired, please provide update
Ruiz,Ay_stal 10/10/2023 3:16PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:8/1/2023
Hold End Date:10/1/2023
Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe.
.Quinones, Erick 8/1/2023 10:49AM
mspwa-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 2/ i
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023
NYSCEF 10:58AM
11/29/23,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023
HPD : Other (see comments)
Hold expired, please provide hold update
Ruiz, Crystal 7/31/2023 12:06PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:7/7/2023
Hold End Date:7/27/2023
Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe.
Raine, John 7/7/2023 7:05PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:4/13/2023
Hold End Date:7/6/2023
Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe.
Robert-Martin, Kristin 4/7/2023 2:58PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:1/13/2023
Hold End Date:4/13/2023
Hold Start date corrected.
Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe.
Campbell, Denise 1/13/2023 12:59PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:12/13/2022
Hold End Date:4/13/2023
Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe.
Campbell, Denise 1/13/2023 12:57PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:12/7/2022
Hold End Date:1/6/2023
Hold Extension doc uploaded. Thank you.
Campbell, Denise 12/7/2022 10:50AM
HPD: Other (see comments)
Hold Expired 11/25/2022; Provide update
Mercklina., Christine 12/1/2022 1:58PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:10/26/2022
mspwµ-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 3/ 5
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023
NYSCEF 10:58AM
11/29/:!3,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023
Hold End Date:11/25/2022
Hold granted to allow owner to remedy condition.
Campbell, Denise 10/26/2022 12:09PM
HPD: Other (see comments)
Hold expired, please provide hold update
Ruiz, Crystal 10/21/2022 10:19AM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:9/16/2022
Hold End Date:10/16/2022
Hold extension granted.
Robert-Martin, Kristin 9/16/2022 2:35PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:9/2/2022
Hold End Date:9/16/2022
Hold granted to allow owner to remedy condition.
Campbell, Denise 9/2/2022 2:57PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:8/26/2022
Hold End Date:9/2/2022
Hold to allow owner to complete design of repairs and to proceed with such
repairs under lawful permit.
Campbell, Denise 8/26/2022 2:38PM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:8/19/2022
Hold End Date:8/26/2022
Hold to allow owner to submit plans and applications, obtain permits and
commence repair work.
Raine, John 8/19/2022 6:09PM
DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed)
Letter requested has been uploaded.
Ca obell, Denise 7/28/2022 1:06PM
HPD: Other (see comments)
Please upload hold resc letter
Ruiz, Crystal 7/28/2022 7:50AM
DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed)
mspwt-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 4/5
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023
NYSCEF 10:58 AM
11/29/:t3,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023
Owner has failed to provide adequate and complete plans as required to
complete their deficient filing. Execute letter uploaded
Campbell, Denise 7/28/2022 7:45AM
DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will
Complying monitor)
Hold Start Date:7/14/2022
Hold End Date:7/25/2022
Hold to allow owner to submit plans and applications, obtain permits and
commence repair work.
Campbell, Denise 7/14/2022 9:41AM
DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed)
PE J. Brown submitted revised request for hold with revised report /
proposal which is not adequate to justify hold. Hold is denied, and HPD may
proceed.
Raine, John 6/21/2022 7:58PM
DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed)
PE J. Brown submitted request for hold with report / proposal which is not
adequate to justify hold. Hold is denied, and HPD may proceed.
Raine, John 6/15/2022 6:21PM
DOB: Other (see comments)
spoke with owner Lisa Fiekowsky (347)268-2961. Alerted her to this ED for
demo and sent her the information required for a hold. HOLD was requested
but not granted at this time.
Amoia, Lisa 5/6/2022 3:21PM
HPD: Pre-Field Work Process Started
Attempted owner outreach, Lisa Silversmith 718-789-6870, no answer,
voicemail full.
Hall, Dawn 5/6/2022 2:31PM
DOB: Declaration Signed by BC
- ED signed DBC Lisa Amoia --
by
Robert-Martin, Kristin 5/5/2022 11:22AM
Home Declarations
Office of the Mayor 2008.
mspwa-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 5/5
Document Filed Date
December 01, 2023
Case Filing Date
August 29, 2023
Category
Other Real Property - Unsafe Buildings
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 16 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023 EXHIBIT D FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023 NYSCEF 10:58 AM 11/29/23,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023 Emergency Declaration Database Home Declarations Welcome Rachel ! [ Logout ] 451 Convent Avenue, Manhattan 16879 --- Submit New Status --- Declaration Information A Num Street Boro BIN Block Lot City Owned 451 Convent Avenue Manhattan v . 1061556 ; 2064 49 3 Landmark Work Action to Take: DOB Emergency Declaration Number: OBackfill HPD Complaint Number: OBrace and Shore: Building OBrace and Shore: Retaining Wall Declaration Priority: Emergency v GGrade and Fence Site Erect Fence or Sidewalk Shed Emergency Declaration Issued ORepair Fence or Sidewalk Shed 5/5/2022 V Date (date signed by BC): GFull Demolition Request General Comments: OPartial Demolition Request Remedy : Fully Demolish the building . Grade and fence site. OSeal Building .... OOther (specify) Attachments: File Name A_dd (d ED 451 Convent Ave_.pf X Authorization Letter 16879,pdf 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD letter - X 7-14-22.pg 451 Convent Avenue - EXECUTE LETTER #16879.pdf X 451 Convent Avenue - Rescission 7-28-22.p 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD letter X S-19-22.pg 451 - HOLD - 8- Convent Avenue 26-22.pH 451 Convent Avenue - 9-2-22 HOLD .p X mspwa-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 1/ FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023 NYSCEF DOC. 11/29/23, 10:58 NO. AM 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn Letter 9-16-22.pdf X 451 Convent Avenue - Hold Extn Letter 10-26-22.pdf X 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn Letter - 12-07-22.pdf 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD EXTN - X 1-13-23.pdf 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn Letter 04-07-23.pdf 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD Extn Letter 07-07-2023.pdf 451 Convent Avenue - Hold Extn Letter 08-01-23.pdf X 451 Convent - BOLD EXTN - Aveppe 10-11-23.pdf 451 Convent Avenue - HOLD EXTN - 11-3-23.pdf Status History DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:11/3/2023 Hold End Date:12/3/2023 Hold to allow owner to remedy condition. Thank you. Campbell, Denise 11/3/2023 3:42PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:10/2/2023 Hold End Date:11/2/2023 Hold to allow owner to remedy condition. Campbell, Denise 10/11/2023 1:39PM HPD: Other (see comments) Hold expired, please provide update Ruiz,Ay_stal 10/10/2023 3:16PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:8/1/2023 Hold End Date:10/1/2023 Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe. .Quinones, Erick 8/1/2023 10:49AM mspwa-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 2/ i FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023 NYSCEF 10:58AM 11/29/23,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023 HPD : Other (see comments) Hold expired, please provide hold update Ruiz, Crystal 7/31/2023 12:06PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:7/7/2023 Hold End Date:7/27/2023 Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe. Raine, John 7/7/2023 7:05PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:4/13/2023 Hold End Date:7/6/2023 Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe. Robert-Martin, Kristin 4/7/2023 2:58PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:1/13/2023 Hold End Date:4/13/2023 Hold Start date corrected. Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe. Campbell, Denise 1/13/2023 12:59PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:12/13/2022 Hold End Date:4/13/2023 Hold to allow owner to complete work necessary to make premise safe. Campbell, Denise 1/13/2023 12:57PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:12/7/2022 Hold End Date:1/6/2023 Hold Extension doc uploaded. Thank you. Campbell, Denise 12/7/2022 10:50AM HPD: Other (see comments) Hold Expired 11/25/2022; Provide update Mercklina., Christine 12/1/2022 1:58PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:10/26/2022 mspwµ-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 3/ 5 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023 NYSCEF 10:58AM 11/29/:!3,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023 Hold End Date:11/25/2022 Hold granted to allow owner to remedy condition. Campbell, Denise 10/26/2022 12:09PM HPD: Other (see comments) Hold expired, please provide hold update Ruiz, Crystal 10/21/2022 10:19AM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:9/16/2022 Hold End Date:10/16/2022 Hold extension granted. Robert-Martin, Kristin 9/16/2022 2:35PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:9/2/2022 Hold End Date:9/16/2022 Hold granted to allow owner to remedy condition. Campbell, Denise 9/2/2022 2:57PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:8/26/2022 Hold End Date:9/2/2022 Hold to allow owner to complete design of repairs and to proceed with such repairs under lawful permit. Campbell, Denise 8/26/2022 2:38PM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:8/19/2022 Hold End Date:8/26/2022 Hold to allow owner to submit plans and applications, obtain permits and commence repair work. Raine, John 8/19/2022 6:09PM DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed) Letter requested has been uploaded. Ca obell, Denise 7/28/2022 1:06PM HPD: Other (see comments) Please upload hold resc letter Ruiz, Crystal 7/28/2022 7:50AM DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed) mspwt-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 4/5 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/01/2023 02:47 PM INDEX NO. 158574/2023 NYSCEF 10:58 AM 11/29/:t3,DOC. NO. 16 Declaration RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/01/2023 Owner has failed to provide adequate and complete plans as required to complete their deficient filing. Execute letter uploaded Campbell, Denise 7/28/2022 7:45AM DOB: Hold - Owner (DOB will Complying monitor) Hold Start Date:7/14/2022 Hold End Date:7/25/2022 Hold to allow owner to submit plans and applications, obtain permits and commence repair work. Campbell, Denise 7/14/2022 9:41AM DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed) PE J. Brown submitted revised request for hold with revised report / proposal which is not adequate to justify hold. Hold is denied, and HPD may proceed. Raine, John 6/21/2022 7:58PM DOB: Hold Denied (HPD must proceed) PE J. Brown submitted request for hold with report / proposal which is not adequate to justify hold. Hold is denied, and HPD may proceed. Raine, John 6/15/2022 6:21PM DOB: Other (see comments) spoke with owner Lisa Fiekowsky (347)268-2961. Alerted her to this ED for demo and sent her the information required for a hold. HOLD was requested but not granted at this time. Amoia, Lisa 5/6/2022 3:21PM HPD: Pre-Field Work Process Started Attempted owner outreach, Lisa Silversmith 718-789-6870, no answer, voicemail full. Hall, Dawn 5/6/2022 2:31PM DOB: Declaration Signed by BC - ED signed DBC Lisa Amoia -- by Robert-Martin, Kristin 5/5/2022 11:22AM Home Declarations Office of the Mayor 2008. mspwa-dobint03/IEDA/Declarations/Declaration.aspx?decid=16879 5/5