No Value: SIMON SALLY vs. ASPERILLA MARK MD

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                DAKik                                                   IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
97-605                                                    OT JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
                                                        CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA

                                                        CASE NO.       00-120 CA


SALLY SIMON, as Personal
Representative of the Estate                                                                           mn
                                                                                                       cS
of Michael Simon                                                                                       63
                                                                                                       =
                     Plaintiff,                                                                        23

VS.

MARK ASPERILLA,                   M.D.                                                                 o>
MARK ASPERILLA,                   M.D.,    P.A.                                                        wo
a Florida corporation,              DALE
GREENBERG, M.D., RONALD
CONSTINE, M.D., LEVY BAKER
CONSTINE & GREENBERG, M.D
P.A.,   a Florida corporation,             SAMUEL
ESTEPA,      M.D.,       PRIMARY CARE
PHYSICIANS,            INC.,      a Florida corpora-
tion, THOMAS K. WANZY, M.D., THOMAS
WANZY, M_D., P.A., a Florida corporation
BALAK. NANDIGAM, M.D., CHARLOTTE                                       PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO
MEDICAL ASSOCIATES, P.A., a Florida                                      EQUEST TO PRODUCE O
corporation, MOIDEN MOOPEN, M.D                                        DEF., NASIR KHALIDI, M.D
MOIDEN MOOPEN, M.D., P.A., a
Florida corporation, CARLOS MAAS, M.D
P.A.,   CARLOS MAAS, M.D., P.A., a
Florida corporation, NASIR KHALIDI, M.D.
NASIR KHALIDI, M.D. & SAKINA KHALID!
M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, ST.
JOSEPH'S EMERGENCY MEDICAL
PHYSICIANS,           a Florida corporation
FRANK COLUNGA,                    M.D.,    CHRIS
MICKELSON, M.D                                                1074884 Dat Charlotte   County Clerk
                                                               Case#:0       00012008 “sos: :47 id: 54

                                                                ii wii tit
                     Defendants                                                                 es: 0006




  KOLTUN & LAZAR,         P.A.,    ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7101 S.W. 102"° AVENUE, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791
Simon v, Asperilla, M.D., etal., Case No. 00-120-CA


       COMES     NOW,    the Plaintiff, SALLY SIMON,        as Personal Representative of the

Estate of Michael Simon, by and through her undersigned attorney, and in response to the

Request To Produce propounded to said party by Defendant, NASIR KHALIDI, M.D., on

February 2, 2000, states as follows:

       1       Response to Request No.     a, none.

       2      Response to Request No. b, death certificate attached.

              Response to Request No. c, attached.

              Response to Request No. d, none.

              Response to Request No. e, copy of probate file attached.

              Response to Request No. f, to be furnished.

              Response to Request No       g, to be furnished.

              Response to Request No. h, not in possession of Plaintiff.

              Response to Request No. i, attached are copies of individual tax returns re

              Michael Simon and Sarah (Sally) Simon for period: 1996-1998; income tax

              returns, Jolly Roger Boat Rental, Inc. for period: 1986-1993; and income tax

              returns, Home Port Marine Services, Inc., for period: 1989-1997.

       10     Response to Request No. j, none.

       11     Response to Request No. k, none.

      12      Response to Request No. I, none.

      13.     Response to Request No. m, none.

      14      Response to Request No. n, none.


 KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7101 S.W. 102° AVENUE, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791
Simon v. Asperilla, M.D., etal., Case No. 00-120-CA

      15      Response to Request No. 0, N/A as to location of incident. Objection, work

             product.      Photos are in possession of undersigned and will be available for

             inspection at a mutually convenient time and place.

      16     Response to Request No. p, medical records are voluminous and have

             previously      been   provided.   Hf this Defendant     wants     Plaintiff's counsel

             to photocopy an additional set, they will be happy to do so provided that they

             are reimbursed the cost of photocopying and clerical fees.

      17.    Response to Request No. q, see response to (p) above.

      18     Response to Request No. r, see attached letter from Medicaid.

      19.    Response to Request No. s, none.

      20     Response       to Request No. t, bills, etc. re funeral and burial expenses are

             attached.

     21      Response to Request No. u, undetermined at this time.

     22      Response to Request No. v, attached are copies of following:
                     (a)      Diploma,   Hofstra University re Michael        Simon   - earned     BA
                              (1964)
                     (b)      Certificate, Empire State Military Academy - Officer Candidate
                              School - completion of course (1967)
                     (c)      Diploma, Long Island University
                     (d)      Certificates of Achievement, Mariner Outboards (1989 & 1990)
                     (e)      Student Evaluation Report re Home Port Marine (1987)
                     ()       Certificate of Achievement, MerCruises Stern Drives &
                              Inboards - Certified Technician (1991)
                     (g)      Advanced Service Training Certificate, Johnson Motors (1974)
                    (h)       Service Training Certificates, OMC Stern Drive (1974, 1975)
                    (i)       Certificate re electrical instrumentation, Volvo Penta (1976)
                    4)        Certificate, Comprehensive Service Course, Mariner Service
                              Training Center (1982, 1985)
                    {k)       Certificate, Course of Instruction, MerCruises Stern Drives &
                              Inboards (1985)
KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7101 S.W. 102"° AVENUE, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791
Simon v. Asperilla, M.D., etal., Case No. 00-120-CA


      23      Response to Request No. w, none.

      24      Response to Request No. x, Will of decedent attached.

      25      Response to Request No. y, none.

      26     Response     to Request    No. z, objection,     attorney-client privilege / work

             product.

      27     Response to Request No. aa, copies of all Notices of Intent are attached.

      28     Response to Request No. bb, copy, documentation from Public Consulting

             Group, Inc. as to subrogation lien of Medicaid is attached.

      29     Response to Request No. cc, none.

      30.    Response to Request No. dd, (1) none; (2) none; (3) none; (4) none; (5)

             objection, work product.     Without waiving said objection, Plaintiff has not

             determined which experts she will use at trial, and therefore, this request is

             premature.    Plaintiff has not received any written reports from any experts.


                                                  KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A.
                                                  Attorneys for Plaintiff
                                                  7101 S.W. 102 Avenue
                                                  Miami, FL 33173
                                                  305    595-6791 - Dade
                                                  305    595-5400 - Fascimile


                                                 Mout oll
                                                  DENNIS A. KOLTUN
                                                  Fla. Bar No. 163040




KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7101 S.W. 102"° AVENUE, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
                           RE: SIMON V. ASPERILLA, M.D., ETAL.
                                    CASE NO. 00-120 CA


           EREBY CERTIFY that true and correct copies of the foregoing were mailed this
1        day of March, 2000, to:



THOMAS A. CULMO, Esq.                          KENNETH C. DEACON, JR., ESQ.
Thomas A. Culmo, P.A.                          Deacon & Moulds, P.A.
Co-Counsel for Plaintiff                       Attorneys for Defs, Dr. Maas,
2950 Southwest 27" Avenue, #100                and for Defs, Dr. Moopen
Miami, FL 33133                                P.O. Box 16607
                                               St. Petersburg, FL 33733-6607

JOHN C. HAMILTON, ESQ.
Wicker, Smith, Tutan, O'Hara,                  CRAIG R. STEVENS, ESQ.
McCoy, Graham & Ford, P.A.                     George, Hart z, Lundeen & Fulmer
Attorneys for Defs, Dr. Khalidi                Attorneys for Defs Greenberg, Constine,
P.O. Box 2152                                  & Levy, Baker, Constine & Greenberg
100 North Tampa Street, #3650                  2000 Main Street, #402
Tampa, FL 33601-2152                           Fort Myers, FL 33901


RONALD H. JOSEPHER, ESQ.                       ROSS L. FOGLEMAN, III, ESQ.
Josepher & Batteese, P.A.                      Fogleman & Rosenkcoetter, P.A.
Attorneys for Defs, Dr. Wazny                  Attorneys for Defs, Nandigmam,   M.D.
First Union Plaza, Suite 1190                         & Charlotte Med Associates, P.A.
100 S. Ashley Street                           3400 S. Tamiami Trail, Suite 302
Tampa, FL 33602                                Sarasota, FL 34239
RALPH L. MARCHBANK, JR., ESQ.
Attorney for Def, Dr. Colunga and
St. Josephs Emergency Medical Physicians
P.O. Box 3979
Sarasota, FL 34230

BENITO H. DIAZ, ESQ.
Diaz & Morel-Saruski
Attorneys for Defs., Samuel Estepa, MD
& Primary Care Phys. Organization
2912 Douglas Road
Coral Gables, FL 33134

LYNN H. GROSECLOSE, ESQ.
Thompson Goodis Thompson
Groseclose & Richardson, P.A.
Attorneys for Defs., Asperilla, MD
100 Wailace Avenue, #240
Sarasota, FL 34237




                                           KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A
                                           Co-Counsel for Plaintiff
                                           7101 S.W. 102 Avenue
                                           Miami, FL 33173
                                           305    595-6791 - Dade