No Value: SIMON SALLY vs. ASPERILLA MARK MD

On July 08, 129 a No Value was filed involving a dispute between Simon Sally, and Asperilla Mark Md, Asperilla Mark Md Pa, Charlotte Medical Asscoi, Colunga Frank Md, Constine Ronald Md, Dale Greenberg Md, Estepa Samual Md, Khalidi Nasir Md, Khalidi Sakina Md, Levy Baker Constine Et A, Maas Carlos E Md, Maas Carlos E Md Pa, Mickelson Chris Md, Moopen Moiden Md, Moopen Moiden Md Pa, Nandigam Bala Md, Primary Care Physicians, St Josephs Emergency Med, Thomasz K Wazny Md Pa, Wazny Thomasz K Mc, for MALPRACTICE - CA in the District Court of Charlotte County.

Preview
an
nancy sensesbtor

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 20™
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA

GENERAL JURISDICTION DIVISION

CASE NO: 00-120 CA

SALLY SIMON, as Personal Representative
of the Estate of MICHAEL SIMON,
co
Plaintiff,

VS.
wo
ma we
MARK ASPERILLA, M.D., MARK ASPERILLA, M.D.,*
La
P.A., a Florida Corporation, DALE GREENBERG, M.D.,
n>
RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., LEVY, BAKER, CONSTINE a
& GREENBERG, M.D., P.A., a Florida Corporation,
SAMUEL ESTEPA, M.D., NASIR KHALIDI, M.D., NASIR
KHALIDI & SAKINA KHALIDI, M.D., P.A., a Florida Corporation,
and CONRAD EPPING KOERPER, M.D., COLEMAN &
CASTELLON, M.D., P.A., a/k/a CHARLOTTE RADIOLOGY
GROUP, and BON SECOURS-ST, JOSEPH HOSPITAL, a
Florida Corporation,

Defendants.

EE’
P WI IT LIST

COMES NOW, the Plaintiff, SALLY SIMON, as Personal Representative of the
i
Estate of MICHAEL SIMON, by and through her undersigned counsel, and pursuant

to this Court’s instructions at the October 26" Case Management Conference and

pursuant to Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.280 identified the following witnesses and exhibits:

WITNESSES Charlotte County Clerk
ED 1236138 Date : 01/22/01 - 09:22:31 id: 54
1 SALLY SIMON Ww" or Case#: 00000120CA P ages: 0013
21495 Eldrid Ave.
Pt. Charlotte, FL 33952
a
AON ll
CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 856-4004
nes ira

CASE NO: 00-120 CA
DANIEL SIMON
15831 E. Mercer Place
Aurora, Colorado 80013

MARK ASPERILLA, M.D.
3300 Tamiami Trail
Suite 102 #A
Port Charlotte, Fl 33952

DALE GREENBERG, M.D.
2450 Harbor Boulevard
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

RONALD CONSTINE, M.D.
1450 Harbor Boulevard
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

SAMUEL ESTEPA, M.D.
713 E. Marion Avenue
Suite 205
Punta Gorda, FL 33950

NASIR KHALIDI, M.D.
2595 Harbor Boulevard.
Suite 206
Port Charlotte, FL 33949-1090

CONRAD KOERPER, M.D.
Shanon Medical Center
120 East Beauregard Avenue
San Angelo, Texas 76903

CARLOS MAAS, M.D.
1775 Citron Street
Charlotte Harbor, FL 33980

10 BALA NANDIGAM, M.D.
2400 Harbor Blvd.
Suite #22
Port Charlotte, Fl 33952

CULMO & CULMO, P.A,, 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 886-4004

3 ck :
MA AAR A NANO TIT ALM NAOH
AACN DSI SHB
pie menshtgp en

CASE NO: 00-120 CA
1 MOIDEN MOOPEN, M.D.
2400 Harbor Boulevard
Suite 19
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

12 THOMAS WAZNY, M.D.
2400 Harbor Boulevard
Suite 14
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

13 JAMES WHITE, M.D.
St. Joseph Bon-Secours Hospital
Radiology Department
2500 Harbor Boulevard
Port Charlotte, Florida 33952

14. DANIEL TUFARIELLO, M.D.
St. Joseph Bon-Secours Hospital
Radiology Department
2500 Harbor Boulevard
Port Charlotte, Florida 33952

15. MAURICIO CASTELLON, M.D.
Fawcett Memorial Hospital
Radiology Department
21298 Olean Bivd.
Port Charlotte, Florida 33952

16 VAN COLEMAN, M.D.
23283 Aberdeen Avenue
Port Charlotte, Florida

17 STEVEN TUCCI, M.D. Treating Physician
3280 Tamiami Trail
Port Charlotte, Florida

18. CHARLES PALMINTERI, M.D. - Treating Physician
Charlotte County Health Department
544 East Grace Street
Punta Gorda, FL 33950

19, CATHY CRISS, DO. Treating Physician
1685 Tamiami Trail
Murdock, Florida 33948

CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 856-4004
°
CASE NO: 00-120 CA

20 STEVEN HALASZ, M.D. Treating Physician
1685 Tamiami Trail
Murdock, Florida 33948

21 KEVIN MCGARABAN, M.D. Treating Physician
3251 Procter Road
Sarasota, Florida

22 ANDREW KINSKY, M.D. Treating Physician
1875 Floyd Street
Sarasota, Florida

23 MARK LIPMAN, M.D. Treating Physician
1875 Floyd Street
Sarasota, Florida

24 DR. MOBELY Treating Physician
Sarasota Plastic Surgery
1851 Hawthorne Street
Sarasota, Florida

25 JOHN NORA, M.D. Treating Physician
Sarasota, Florida

26. JOSE I. CABRERRA, M.D. Treating Physician
2525 Harbor Blvd., #303
Port Charlotte, Florida 33952

27 KENNETH LEVY, M.D. Treating Physician
2450 Harbor Boulevard
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

28 ROBERT HANSEL, M.D, Treating Physician
2450 Haybor Boulevard
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

29 STEVEN BAKER, M.D. Treating Physician
2450 Harbor Boulevard
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 - (305) 856-4004
Pen AUN ME meneenibointsoec

“
CASE NO: 00-120 CA

30. JOANNE TOMPKINS, RN Treating Nurse
3762G Tamiami Trail
Port Charlotte, Florida

31 VERNE HALL FactWitness/Family Friend
6309 Austrian Blvd.
Punta Gorda, Florida 33982

32 SHAWN HALL FactWitness/Family Friend
6309 Austrian Blvd.
Punta Gorda, Florida 33982

33 DENA HALL “Fact Witness/Family Friend
6309 Austrian Blvd.
Punta Gorda, Florida 33982

34 MARILYN COLEMAN, M.S. Grief Counselor
Hager Psychiatric Ctr
4344 Laurast
Port Charlotte, FL 33952

35 PAT TRINCHETELLA, RN Treating Nurse
727 Indian Creek Lane
Punta Gorda, Florida

36 HONORABLE PETER BELL Family Friend.
322 Tamiami Trail
Punta Gorda, 33950

37 BARBARA SCOTT Family Friend
Clerk of the Court
Charlotte County Courthouse
5 350 E. Marion Avenue
Punta Gorda, Florida 33950

38 DONALD ROSS Family Friend
18505 Paulson Street
Port Charlotte, Florida

CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 856-4004

wae
sect

CASE NO: 00-120 CA

39. KATHLEEN COPPOLA Family Friend
18798 Countryman Avenue
Port Charlotte, Florida

40 EDELYN BISHOP Treating Psychiatric
22131 Clinton Avenue Nurse
Port Charlotte, Florida

41 Medical Records Custodian from Bon Secours-St. Josephs Hospital

42 Medical Records Custodian from Sarasota Memorial Hospital

43 Medical Records Custodian from Health South Hospital in Sarasota

44 Medical Records Custodian from LakeSide Terrace Skilled Nursing
Center

45 Medical Records Custodian from Columbia Fawcett Hospital

46 Medical Records Custodian from Levy Baker Constine Greenberg, M.D.,
PA.

47 Medical Records Custodian from Bala Nandigam, M.D.

48 Medical Records Custodian from Charlotte County Emergency Medical
Services

49 Medical Records Custodian from Charlotte County Chiropractic Clinic

50. Medical Records Custodian from Sarasota Anesthesiologist, P.A.

SI Medical Records Custodian from Murdock Family Medicine

52 Medical Records Custodian from Moiden Moopen, M.D., P.A.

53 Medical Records Custodian from Columbia Doctor’s Hospital of
Sarasota

54 Medical Records Custodian from Kennedy White Orthopedic Center

55 Medical Records Custodian from Intermedic Health Centers
6
CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33123 + (305) 856-4004
CASE NO: 00-120 CA

56 Medical Records Custodian from Samuel Estepa, M.D.

57 Medical Records Custodian from Sarasota Plastic Surgery

58 Medical Records Custodian from Sarasota Memorial Hospital Radiology
Associates, P.A.

59 Medical Records Custodian from O. Sam Van Dam

60 Medical Records Custodian from Richard W. King, M.D. and Kevin
McGarahan, M.D.

61 Medical Records Custodian from Swing, Cang & Associates

62 Medical Records Custodian from Jose I. Cabrerra

63 Medical Records Custodian from Moenning & Moenning, P.A.

64 Medical Records Custodian from Lung Associates of Sarasota

65. Medical Records Custodian of Vascular Associates of Sarasota

66. Medical Records Custodian of Nasir Khalidi

67 Medical Records Custodian of Mark Asperilla

68 Medical Records Custodian of Charlotte County EMS

69 Medical Records Custodian of Coleman & Castellon, M.D., P.A.

70. Medical Records Custodian of South Florida Wound Care Center

71 Medical Records Custodian of Dr. Kenneth York

72 Medical Records Custodian of Englewood Walk-In Clinic

E IBIT LIST “

1 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Mark Asperilla M.D.

7
CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE $00, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 856-4004
“
cm oer

CASE NO: 00-120 CA
*
Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Samuel Estepa, M.D.

Any and all medical records, reports, bills and rays and diagnostic
studies from Nasir Khalidi, M.D.

Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Carlos Maas, M.D.

Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and. diagnostic
studies from Bala Nandigam, M.D.

Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Mooiden Moopen, M.D. «

Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Thomas Wazny, M.D.

Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Steven Tucci, M.D.
«
Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Charles Palminteri, M.D.

10 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Cathy Criss, DO.

11 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Steven Halasz, M.D.

12 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Kevin McGarahan, M.D.

13 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Andrew Kinsky, M.D. s

14 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Mark Lipman, M.D.

15 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Dr. Mobely.
8 a

CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 856-4004

a
CASE NO: 00-120 CA

16. Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from John Nora, M.D.

17. Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Jose I. Cabrerra, M.D. 8

18 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Bon Secours-St. Josephs Hospital

19 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Sarasota Memorial Hospital
*
20 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Health South Hospital in Sarasota

21 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Lakeside Terrace Skilled Nursing Center

22 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Columbia Fawcett Hospital

23 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Levy Baker Constine Greenberg, M.D., P.A.

24. Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Charlotte County Emergency Medical Services

25 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Charlotte County Chiropractic Clinic

26 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Sarasota Anesthesiologist, P.A.

27 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Murdock Family Medicine

28 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Columbia Doctor’s Hospital of Sarasota

29 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Kennedy White Orthopedic Center

CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (308) 886-4004

eon
ey
Lente

CASE NO: 00-120 CA
*.
30 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Intermedic Health Centers

31 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Sarasota Plastic Surgery Associates

32 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Sarasota Memorial Hospital Radiology Associates, P.A.

33 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from O. Sam Van Dam

34 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Swing, Cang & Associates"

35 Any and. all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Jose I. Cabrerra, M.D

36 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Moenning & Moenning, P.A.
.
37 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Lung Associates of Sarasota

38 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Vascular Associates of Sarasota

39 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Charlotte County EMS

40. Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Coleman & Castellon, M.D., P.A.

4] Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from South Florida Wound Care Center

42 Any and all medical records, reports, bills and x-rays and diagnostic
studies from Englewood Walk-In Clinic

43 Michael Simon’s birth certificate

10
CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 856-4004
pes Ha entoneretare ctabrtoa einen

CASE NO: 00-120 CA

44 Sally Simon’s birth certificate.

45 Michael and Sally Simon’s marriage certificate.

46 Michael Simon’s college and graduate degrees.

47 Michael Simon’s funeral expenses

48 Michael Simon’s funeral sign-in book

49 Michael Simon’s funeral sympathy cards

50. Michael Simon’s marine mechanic certificates

51 Michael Simon’s income tax returns

52 Photos and videos of the Plaintiff

53 Social Security Administrations Records

54 Telephone records

55 Photos of scrotal decubitus ulcers

56 Photos of sacral decubitus ulcers

57 Records pertaining to home modifications

58 Photos of home modifications

59 Mortality tables

6
CULMO & CULMO, P.A,, 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33133 + (305) 856-4004
CASE NO: 00-120 CA

CERTIFICATE OF SERVI E

WE HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was

served by mail on: ALL COUNSEL OF RECORD on this iS day of January, 2001.

CULMO & CULMO, P.A
Co-counsel for the Plaintiff
2400 South Dixie Highway
Suite 100
Miami, Florida 33133
Phone: (305) 856-4004
Fax: (305) 854-5445

THOMAS A. CULMO
Florida Bar: 775479

| -and -

KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A.
Co-counsel for Plaintiff
Sunset International West
7000 S.W. 97" Avenue, Suite 210
Miami, Florida 33173
Phone: (305) 595-6791
Fax: (305) 595-5400
By: Aly dull (bae(>)
DENNIS KOLTUN °
Florida Bar:163040

FACASES\SIMON\PLEADING\Witness&ExhibitIst

CULMO & CULMO, P.A., 2400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, SUITE 100, MIAMI, FL 33132 + (308) 656-4004

a
SALLY SIMON, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Simon, Deceased

cl iF Vv

1 Lynn H. Groseclose, Esq RAYMONDA. REISER, ESQ
Attorney for Asperilla Attorney for Conrad Koerper
100 Wallace Avenue Reiser & Allison
Suite 240 1 SE 3" Avenue, Suite 1860
Sarasota, Florida 34237 Miami, Florida 33131-1704
Phone: 941-365-0540 Phone: 305-379-5316
Fax: 941-366-5060 Fax: 305-379-6917

Craig Stevens, Esq. 7. BENITO DIAZ, ESQUIRE
Attorney for Constine, Greenberg & Levy Attorney for Samuel Estepa
George, Hartz, Lundeen & Fulmer Diaz & Morel-Saruski
2000 Main Street, Suite 402 2912 Douglas Road
Ft. Myers, Florida 33901 Coral Gables, Fi. 33134
Phone: 941-337-7787 Phone: 305-529-9910 Ext. 12
Fax: 941-337-4303 Fax: 305-529-9913

John Hamilton, Esq
Attorney for Dr. Khalidi CLIFFORD L. SOMERS, ESQ.
400 North Tampa Street Attérmeys for Coleman & Castellon
Suite 3650 Barr, Murman & Tonelli, P.A
Tampa, Florida 33602 201 East Kennedy Bivd., #1750
Phone: 813-222-3939 Tampa, FL 33602
Fax: 813-222-3938 Telephone : 813-223-3951
Fax: 813-229-2254 or
DENNIS KOLTUN, ESQUIRE Fax: 813-209-0214
Co-counsel for Sally Simon
7101 S. W. 102" Avenue THOMASA. CULMO, ESQ
Miami, FL 33173 Culmo & Culmo, P.A.
Phone: 305-595-6791 Co-Counsel for Sally Simon
Fax: 305-595-5400 2400 South Dixie Highway
Suite 100
KELLY JO SMITH, ESQ. Miami, Fiorida 33133
Attorneys for Bon Secours-St. Joseph Phone: 305-856-4004
Hahn, Morgan & Lamb Fax: 305-854-5445
2701 N. Rocky Point Dr., #410 «
Tampa, Florida 33607
Phone: 813-281-9700
Fax: 813-287-2900

anne

Case Info

Judge

PORTER, LISA S Track Judge’s New Case

Case No.

(Subscribe to View)

Document Filed Date

January 13, 2024

Case Filing Date

July 08, 129

County

Parties

ASPERILLA MARK MD Defendant
ASPERILLA MARK MD PA Defendant
BENITO DIAZ Evidence Submitter
CHARLOTTE MEDICAL ASSCOI Defendant
COLUNGA FRANK MD Defendant
CONSTINE RONALD MD Defendant
DALE GREENBERG MD Defendant
ESTEPA SAMUAL MD Defendant
KHALIDI NASIR MD Defendant
KHALIDI SAKINA MD Defendant
LEVY BAKER CONSTINE ET A Defendant
MAAS CARLOS E MD Defendant
MAAS CARLOS E MD PA Defendant
MICKELSON CHRIS MD Defendant
MOOPEN MOIDEN MD Defendant
MOOPEN MOIDEN MD PA Defendant
NANDIGAM BALA MD Defendant
PORTER, LISA S Judge
PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIANS Defendant
SIMON SALLY Plaintiff
ST JOSEPHS EMERGENCY MED Defendant
THOMAS CULMO Evidence Submitter
THOMASZ K WAZNY MD PA Defendant
WAZNY THOMASZ K MC Defendant
Claudia Rosenkoetter Attorneys for Defendants
Eugene Smith Attorneys for Defendants
Craig Stevens Attorney
Dennis Koltun Attorney
Jean Kneale Attorneys for Defendants
Jennifer Kerr Attorneys for Defendants
Lynn Groseclose Attorney
Clifford Somers Attorneys for Defendants
Steven Craig Attorneys for Defendants
John Hamilton Attorneys for Defendants
Kimberly Lee Attorneys for Defendants
Raymond Reiser Attorney
Kristin Woolam Attorney
Aaron Bloom Attorney
Jeffrey Hunt Attorney
Kelly Lamb Attorney
H LEE Attorneys for Defendants
Peter Bell Attorney
Ronald Josepher Attorneys for Defendants
Jerry Armbruster Attorney
Ana Saruski Attorneys for Defendants
Jeffrey Hunter Attorney
Kevin Smith Attorneys for Defendants
Mark Haskins Attorneys for Defendants
Ross Fogleman Attorney
Roy Acord Attorney
Anthony Paviglianiti
Kimberly Lent Attorneys for Defendants
David Ross Attorney
Ralph Marchbank Attorneys for Defendants
Scott Albee Attorney
Carl Goldman Attorney
Douglas Lumpkin Attorneys for Defendants
Kenneth Depew Attorney
Michael Simon Attorney
Jeffrey Peairs Attorneys for Defendants
Joni Hamilton Attorney
Fleur Lobree Attorneys for Defendants
Scott Lazar Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Ronald Hart Attorney
Hannah Diaz Attorney
Hector Diaz Attorney
John Crabill Attorneys for Defendants
Ross Leonardi Attorneys for Defendants
Lori Heyer Attorneys for Defendants
Clifford LoCurto Attorneys for Defendants
Douglas Romanik Attorneys for Defendants
Raymond Anderson Attorney
Cari Stevens Attorneys for Defendants
Charles Hamilton Attorney
Kimberly Doud Attorneys for Defendants
Ross Linzer Attorneys for Defendants
Craig Stein Attorney
Thomas Aubin
Kenneth Cross Attorney
Carl Stevens Attorney
Douglas Bischoff Attorney
Craig Rothburd Attorney
J Lee Attorneys for Defendants
Carlos Mas Attorney
Frank Cona Attorney
Kenneth Clarkson Attorney
Robert Coker Attorney
Kim Levy Attorney
Lisa Start Attorney

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.