Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
SEPTEMBER 30,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 983592 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
01 DATE : 9/10/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS
01 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY RE: TENANT'S CLAIM OF NON POSSESSION
01 TO LANDLORD'S REPLACEMENT OF STOREFRONT. .25
02 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
02 REVIEW OF LEASE AND RIDER. REVIEW OF VARIOUS EMAILS AND PHOTOS.
02 PREPARATION OF DRAFT LETTER TO TENANT. FORWARD TO CLIENT FOR REVIEW.
02 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY. 1.20
03 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
03 REVIEW AND RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM TENANT. .10
04 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
04 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH DEFENDANT. TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH SAQ
04 AND VIJAY. .25
05 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
05 REVIEW AND RESPONSE TO EMAILS FROM DEFENDANT. .10
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 1.90 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $665.00
_____ DISBURSEMENTS ____
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 2 ---
SEPTEMBER 30,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 983592 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
DATE : 9/15/21 FEE FOR STANDARD OVERNIGHT FEDEX $22.90
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $687.90
BILLING PERIOD: 8/31/21 THROUGH 9/31/21
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
NOVEMBER 30,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 989093 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
01 DATE : 11/18/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS
01 REVIEW AND RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM CLIENT RE: DEFENDANT'S WITHHOLDING
01 OF RENTS. .10
02 DATE : 11/19/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
02 REVIEW OF EMAIL COMMUNICATION BETWEEN PARTIES. .10
03 DATE : 11/22/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
03 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM CLIENT RE: COMMENCING ACTION. REVIEW OF RENT
03 HISTORY. PREPARATION OF RESPONSE EMAILS TO CLIENT. .20
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .40 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $140.00
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $140.00
BILLING PERIOD: 10/31/21 THROUGH 11/31/21
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
DECEMBER 31,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 991870 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
01 DATE : 12/01/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS
01 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VJAY RE: TENANT VACATUR OF PREMIES AND
01 RETURN OF KEYS. REVIEW RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM CLIENT. .25
02 DATE : 12/10/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
02 ONLINE DEPARTMENT OF STATE SEARCH; REVIEW OF LEASE, RIDR, GUARANTY AND
02 EMAILS IN FILE. CALCULATED LATE FEES. TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY.
02 PREPARATION OF DRAFT OF COMPLAINT. PREPARATION OF SUMMONS. EMAIL
02 COMPLAINT TO CLIENT. 4.75
03 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
03 RECEIPT OF CLIENT VERIFICATION, COLLATED DOCUMENTS FOR SCANNING AND
03 FILING. UPLOADED SUMMONS & COMPLAINT TO EFILE. OPENED EFILE LEASE
03 PROFILE. PREPARATION OF MANDATORY EFILE NOTICE. .50
04 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
04 RECEIPT OF INDEX #. CONFORMED ALL PAPERS. ATTENTION TO FILE RE:
04 SERVICE. .25
05 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
05 REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS SENT BY CLIENT RE: JOSEPH FOLEY ADDRESS. .20
06 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 2 ---
DECEMBER 31,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 991870 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
06 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
06 REVIEW OF CREDIT REPORT FOR ADDITIONAL SERVICE ADDRESS FOR DEFENDANT
06 FOLEY. FORWARD TO CLIENT. .20
07 DATE : 12/16/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
07 REVIEW OF DEFENDANT'S EMAIL. REVIEW OF CLIENT'S EMAIL. DICTATED BRIEF
07 RESPONSE TO GUARANTOR. .10
08 DATE : 12/19/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
08 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM DEFENDANT RE: SERVICE ON SPOUSE. .10
09 DATE : 12/20/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
09 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE. SCAN AND UPLOAD TO EFILE. .20
11 DATE : 12/20/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
11 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE. SCAN AND UPLOAD TO EFILE. .20
10 DATE : 12/21/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
10 PREPRAATION OF CPLR 3215 NOTICE. .25
13 DATE : 12/23/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
13 REVIEW RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM DEFENDANT'S PROCESS SERVER RE:
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 3 ---
DECEMBER 31,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 991870 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
13 DATE : 12/23/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
13 DEFENDANT'S REFUSAL TO ACCEPT PAPERS. .20
12 DATE : 12/29/21 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
12 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVITS OF SERVICE AND ATTENTION TO FILE; PREPARED CPLR
12 NOTICES FOR ALL DEFENDANTS. .40
14 DATE : 12/29/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
14 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FOR SECRETARY OF STATE; UPLOAD TO
14 EFILE. .25
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 7.45 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $2,607.50
JOSHUA NADELBACH = .40 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $140.00
_____ DISBURSEMENTS ____
DATE : 12/13/21 PURCHASE OF INDEX #. $216.28
DATE : 12/16/21 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $70.40
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $3,034.18
BILLING PERIOD: 11/31/21 THROUGH 12/31/21
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
01 DATE : 1/03/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS
01 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM PROCESS SERVER RE: SERVICE ON GUARANTOR. .10
05 DATE : 1/04/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
05 REVIEW OF PROPOSED AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE. DICTATED CHANGES TO AFFIDAVIT
05 BASED ON PHOTO TAKEN BY PROCESS SERVER. .25
06 DATE : 1/04/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
06 SAN AND UPLOAD AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE TO EFILE.CALENDAR DATE FOR ANSWER. .20
02 DATE : 1/05/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
02 TELEPHONE CALL WITH E-FILING CLERK RE: TENANT'S ANSWER THAT WAS NOT
02 E-FILED; REVIEW OF ANSWER AND EMAIL CORRESPONDENCE FROM CLIENT;
02 PREPARED NOTICE OF REJECTION; E-FILED PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF
02 REJECTION .90
07 DATE : 1/05/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
07 REVIEW OF DEFENDANT'S ANSWER WITH COUNTERCLIAMS. SCAN AND EMAIL TO
07 CLIENT WITH INQUIRY. ATTENTION TO FILE RE: MOTION. .20
08 DATE : 1/05/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
08 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF NOTICE OF REJECTION OF ANSWER AND
08 COUNTERCLAIM. .20
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 2 ---
JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
09 DATE : 1/05/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
09 REVIEW OF STRING OF EMAILS SENT BY SAQ RE: TENANT'S OPENING DELAYED. .10
03 DATE : 1/06/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
03 EDITED AND REVISED NOTICE OF REJECTION; E-FILED SAME REJECTING ANSWER
03 E-FILED THIS MORNING .25
10 DATE : 1/06/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
10 REVIEW OF DEFENDAND'S AMENDED ANSWER. DICTTED NOTICE OF REJECTION. .20
11 DATE : 1/06/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
11 REVIW OF DEFENDANT'S THIRD FILING OF ANSWER. ATTENTION TO FILE. EMAIL
11 TO CLIENT. .25
12 DATE : 1/10/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
12 REVIEW OF 4TH AMENDMENT TO COMPLAINT. .10
13 DATE : 1/11/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
13 REVIEW OF NOTICE OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY .10
04 DATE : 1/17/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
04 TELEPHONE CALL WITH VIJAY RE: INFO NEEDED TO REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS .20
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 3 ---
JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
17 DATE : 1/18/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
17 PREPARED REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME .90
14 DATE : 1/19/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
14 REVIEW OF REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS. FORWARD TO CLIENT FOR REVIEW. .20
18 DATE : 1/19/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
18 FINALIZED RESPONSE TO COUNTERCLAIM AND E-FILED SAME .25
15 DATE : 1/27/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
15 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM DEFENDANT'S COUNSEL SEEKING TIME TO FILE AMENDED
15 ANSWER. ATTENTION TO FILE. .20
16 DATE : 1/27/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
16 REVIEW OF STIPULATION EXTENDING DEFENDANT'S TIME TO ANSWER. .10
19 DATE : 1/27/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
19 EMAIL WITH OPPOSING COUNSEL RE: REQUEST TO SERVE AMENDED ANSWER; .10
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 2.20 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $803.00
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 4 ---
JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
JOSHUA NADELBACH = 2.60 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $910.00
_____ DISBURSEMENTS ____
DATE : 12/20/21 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $211.20
DATE : 12/27/21 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $102.30
DATE : 1/03/22 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $70.40
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $2,096.90
BILLING PERIOD: 12/31/21 THROUGH 1/31/22
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
FEBRUARY 28,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 998274 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
01 DATE : 2/01/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS
01 ATTENTION TO FILE RE: STIPULATION EXTENDING DEFENDANT'S TIME TO FILE
01 ANSWER. .10
03 DATE : 2/02/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
03 EMAILS WITH OPPOSING COUNSEL RE: STIPULATION FOR AMENDED ANSWER .25
02 DATE : 2/11/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
02 REVIEW OF DEFENDANT'S ANSWER WITH COUNTERCLIAMS. FORWARD TO CLIENT.
02 ATTENTION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT. .20
04 DATE : 2/14/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
04 REVIEW OF DEFENDANTS' AMENDED ANSWER WITH COUNTERCLAIM COMPARING TO
04 COMPLAINT AND PRIOR FILED ANSWERS .40
05 DATE : 2/15/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
05 EMAILS WITH CLIENT RE: NEED FOR INFORMATION TO REPLY RESPONSE TO
05 COUNTERCLAIM .20
06 DATE : 2/17/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
06 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY AND SOO RE: REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS. .30
07 DATE : 2/17/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 2 ---
FEBRUARY 28,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 998274 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
07 DATE : 2/17/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
07 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM SOQ ATTACHMENT. .10
09 DATE : 2/17/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
09 CORRESPONDENCE WITH CLIENT RE: INFORMATION NEEDED FOR REPLY TO
09 COUNTERCLAIM; CONFERENCE CALL WITH SAQ AND VIJAY CONCERNING
09 DEFENDANTS' ANSWER; SEARCHED INSTAGRAM AND OTHER WEBSITES FOR PICTURES
09 OR STATEMENTS INDICATING WHEN PUNCH HOUSE OPENED 1.00
10 DATE : 2/18/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
10 PREPARED REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM TO AMENDED ANSWER FILED ON 2/11 .50
08 DATE : 2/22/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
08 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS. FORWARD TO CLIENT. .25
11 DATE : 2/22/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
11 EDITED AND REVISED DRAFT OF RESPONSE TO AMENDED ANSWER; E-FILED
11 RESPONSE TO COUNTERCLAIM .40
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .95 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $346.75
JOSHUA NADELBACH = 2.75 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $962.50
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 3 ---
FEBRUARY 28,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 998274 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $1,309.25
BILLING PERIOD: 1/31/22 THROUGH 2/31/22
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
MARCH 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 1990 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
02 DATE : 3/22/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS
02 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: MITIGATION OF DAMAGES .10
01 DATE : 3/28/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
01 REVIEW AND REPLY TO CLIENT RE: STATUS OF CASE AND MOTION. .10
03 DATE : 3/28/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
03 BEGAN DRAFTING MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGEMENT 2.00
04 DATE : 3/29/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
04 CONTINUED WRITING MEMORANDUM OF LAW DISMISSING DEFENSES 1.80
05 DATE : 3/31/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
05 CONTINUED PREPARING FIRST DRAFT OF MEMORANDUM OF LAW 2.00
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
JOSHUA NADELBACH = 5.90 @ $364/HR. TOTAL $2,147.60
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .10 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $36.50
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $2,184.10
BILLING PERIOD: 2/31/22 THROUGH 3/31/22
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
APRIL 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 5721 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
01 DATE : 4/01/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS
01 FINALIZED FIRST DRAFT OF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY
01 JUDGMENT. 3.80
02 DATE : 4/05/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
02 BEGAN DRAFTING AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT 2.20
03 DATE : 4/07/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
03 FINALIZED FIRST DRAFT OF AFFIDAVIT; PREPARED AFFIRMATION, STATEMENT OF
03 FACTS 2.50
04 DATE : 4/08/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
04 EDITED PREPARED FINAL DRAFTS OF ALL MOTION PAPERS 2.80
05 DATE : 4/25/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
05 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF FIRST DRAFT OF SUPPORTING AFFIDAVITS,
05 FORWARD TO CLIENT. REVISED AFFIRMATION, MEMO OF LAW, STATEMENT OF
05 FACTS. 1.50
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
JOSHUA NADELBACH = 11.30 @ $364/HR. TOTAL $4,113.20
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 1.50 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $547.50
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 2 ---
APRIL 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 5721 POSTED BY: IRI
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $4,660.70
BILLING PERIOD: 3/31/22 THROUGH 4/31/22
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
MAY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 9069 POSTED BY: CHR
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
02 DATE : 5/11/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS
02 EMAIL WITH CLIENT REGARDING STATUS OF AFFIDAVIT FOR FILING
02 SUMMARY JUDGMENT. .10
01 DATE : 5/16/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
01 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: ADVISEMENT OF RE-RENTAL. .10
03 DATE : 5/19/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
03 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM CLIENT RE: EXECUTION OF RENEW LEASE WITH NEW
03 TENANT AND MITIGATION OF DAMAGES. REVIEW OF LEASE. .20
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
JOSHUA NADELBACH = .20 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $70.00
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .20 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $73.00
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $143.00
BILLING PERIOD: 4/31/22 THROUGH 5/31/22
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
JUNE 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 12641 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
03 DATE : 6/02/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS
03 REVISED ARREARS IN AFFIDAVIT AS LANDLORD RE-RENTED; EDITED MEMORANDUM
03 OF LAW ; 1.50
01 DATE : 6/03/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
01 REVIEW OF .10
04 DATE : 6/03/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
04 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: BROKER'S INVOICE .10
05 DATE : 6/07/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
05 EDITED AND REVISED STATEMENT OF FACTS AND AFFIRMATION, AND COMPLETED
05 FINAL DRAFT OF ALL MOTION PAPERS 1.40
06 DATE : 6/08/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
06 PREPARED TABLE OF CONTENTS AND TABLE OF AUTHORITIES FOR MEMORANDUM OF
06 LAW PER COURT RULES 1.00
02 DATE : 6/16/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
02 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF SUPPORTING AFFIDAVIT, FORWARD TO CLIENT.
02 REVIEW AND REVISONS TO AFFIRMATION, MEMEO OF LAW AND STATEMENT OF
02 FACTS. 1.50
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 2 ---
JUNE 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 12641 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
07 DATE : 6/21/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
07 EDITED AND REVISED MOTION PAPERS PER EMAIL EDIT FROM CLIENT; EMAIL
07 WITH CLIENT RE: SAME .40
08 DATE : 6/23/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
08 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: BACKUP FOR ELECTRIC CHARGES NEEDED FOR MOTION .10
09 DATE : 6/24/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
09 ATTENTION TO FILE RE: AMENDING MOTION TO INCLUDE ELECTRIC CHARGES
09 THROUGH MARCH 2022. .20
10 DATE : 6/24/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
10 REVIEW OF BACKUP CHARGES FOR ELECTRIC METER SENT BY CLIENT; COLLATED
10 EXHIBITS FOR FILING; EDITED AFFIDAVIT TO INCLUDE THE ELECTRIC FEES
10 FROM 12/21 - 4/22; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME 1.10
11 DATE : 6/27/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH
11 BOOKMARKED MEMORANDUM OF LAW PER COURT RULES; E-FILED MOTION PAPERS;
11 PREPARED RJI; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME .80
----- T O T A L H O U R S -----
JOSHUA NADELBACH = 6.40 @ $364/HR. TOTAL $2,329.60
(CONTINUED)
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
--- PAGE 3 ---
JUNE 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 12641 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 1.80 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $657.00
_____ DISBURSEMENTS ____
DATE : 6/27/22 NYSCEF FILING FEE FOR A NOTICE OF $158.60
MOTION
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $3,145.20
BILLING PERIOD: 5/31/22 THROUGH 6/31/22
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL.
AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK.
NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT
https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE.
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021
<>
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023
BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
377 BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013
(212) 431-1300
JULY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X
INVOICE #: 16313 POSTED BY: STA
HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S
13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872
NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET
APT : **
MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR
-- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D --
Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED
01 DATE : 7/11/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS
01 REVIEW OF THE AFFIDAVIT AND AFFIRMATION FILED IN OPPOSITION TO
01 LANDLORD'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME;
01 BEGAN PREPARING REPLY PAPERS AND PULLING CASES CONCERNING FRAUDULENT
01 INDUCEMENT, THE ONLY "DEFENSE" 1.90
05 DATE : 7/11/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM
05 REVIW OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE AND FOR SUMMARY
05 JUDGMENT.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 SEPTEMBER 30,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 983592 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 01 DATE : 9/10/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS 01 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY RE: TENANT'S CLAIM OF NON POSSESSION 01 TO LANDLORD'S REPLACEMENT OF STOREFRONT. .25 02 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 02 REVIEW OF LEASE AND RIDER. REVIEW OF VARIOUS EMAILS AND PHOTOS. 02 PREPARATION OF DRAFT LETTER TO TENANT. FORWARD TO CLIENT FOR REVIEW. 02 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY. 1.20 03 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 03 REVIEW AND RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM TENANT. .10 04 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 04 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH DEFENDANT. TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH SAQ 04 AND VIJAY. .25 05 DATE : 9/14/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 05 REVIEW AND RESPONSE TO EMAILS FROM DEFENDANT. .10 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 1.90 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $665.00 _____ DISBURSEMENTS ____ (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 2 --- SEPTEMBER 30,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 983592 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED DATE : 9/15/21 FEE FOR STANDARD OVERNIGHT FEDEX $22.90 TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $687.90 BILLING PERIOD: 8/31/21 THROUGH 9/31/21 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 NOVEMBER 30,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 989093 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 01 DATE : 11/18/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS 01 REVIEW AND RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM CLIENT RE: DEFENDANT'S WITHHOLDING 01 OF RENTS. .10 02 DATE : 11/19/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 02 REVIEW OF EMAIL COMMUNICATION BETWEEN PARTIES. .10 03 DATE : 11/22/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 03 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM CLIENT RE: COMMENCING ACTION. REVIEW OF RENT 03 HISTORY. PREPARATION OF RESPONSE EMAILS TO CLIENT. .20 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .40 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $140.00 TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $140.00 BILLING PERIOD: 10/31/21 THROUGH 11/31/21 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 DECEMBER 31,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 991870 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 01 DATE : 12/01/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS 01 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VJAY RE: TENANT VACATUR OF PREMIES AND 01 RETURN OF KEYS. REVIEW RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM CLIENT. .25 02 DATE : 12/10/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 02 ONLINE DEPARTMENT OF STATE SEARCH; REVIEW OF LEASE, RIDR, GUARANTY AND 02 EMAILS IN FILE. CALCULATED LATE FEES. TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY. 02 PREPARATION OF DRAFT OF COMPLAINT. PREPARATION OF SUMMONS. EMAIL 02 COMPLAINT TO CLIENT. 4.75 03 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 03 RECEIPT OF CLIENT VERIFICATION, COLLATED DOCUMENTS FOR SCANNING AND 03 FILING. UPLOADED SUMMONS & COMPLAINT TO EFILE. OPENED EFILE LEASE 03 PROFILE. PREPARATION OF MANDATORY EFILE NOTICE. .50 04 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 04 RECEIPT OF INDEX #. CONFORMED ALL PAPERS. ATTENTION TO FILE RE: 04 SERVICE. .25 05 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 05 REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS SENT BY CLIENT RE: JOSEPH FOLEY ADDRESS. .20 06 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 2 --- DECEMBER 31,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 991870 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 06 DATE : 12/13/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 06 REVIEW OF CREDIT REPORT FOR ADDITIONAL SERVICE ADDRESS FOR DEFENDANT 06 FOLEY. FORWARD TO CLIENT. .20 07 DATE : 12/16/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 07 REVIEW OF DEFENDANT'S EMAIL. REVIEW OF CLIENT'S EMAIL. DICTATED BRIEF 07 RESPONSE TO GUARANTOR. .10 08 DATE : 12/19/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 08 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM DEFENDANT RE: SERVICE ON SPOUSE. .10 09 DATE : 12/20/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 09 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE. SCAN AND UPLOAD TO EFILE. .20 11 DATE : 12/20/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 11 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE. SCAN AND UPLOAD TO EFILE. .20 10 DATE : 12/21/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 10 PREPRAATION OF CPLR 3215 NOTICE. .25 13 DATE : 12/23/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 13 REVIEW RESPONSE TO EMAIL FROM DEFENDANT'S PROCESS SERVER RE: (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 3 --- DECEMBER 31,2021 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 991870 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 13 DATE : 12/23/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 13 DEFENDANT'S REFUSAL TO ACCEPT PAPERS. .20 12 DATE : 12/29/21 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 12 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVITS OF SERVICE AND ATTENTION TO FILE; PREPARED CPLR 12 NOTICES FOR ALL DEFENDANTS. .40 14 DATE : 12/29/21 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 14 REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FOR SECRETARY OF STATE; UPLOAD TO 14 EFILE. .25 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 7.45 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $2,607.50 JOSHUA NADELBACH = .40 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $140.00 _____ DISBURSEMENTS ____ DATE : 12/13/21 PURCHASE OF INDEX #. $216.28 DATE : 12/16/21 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $70.40 TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $3,034.18 BILLING PERIOD: 11/31/21 THROUGH 12/31/21 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 01 DATE : 1/03/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS 01 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM PROCESS SERVER RE: SERVICE ON GUARANTOR. .10 05 DATE : 1/04/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 05 REVIEW OF PROPOSED AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE. DICTATED CHANGES TO AFFIDAVIT 05 BASED ON PHOTO TAKEN BY PROCESS SERVER. .25 06 DATE : 1/04/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 06 SAN AND UPLOAD AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE TO EFILE.CALENDAR DATE FOR ANSWER. .20 02 DATE : 1/05/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 02 TELEPHONE CALL WITH E-FILING CLERK RE: TENANT'S ANSWER THAT WAS NOT 02 E-FILED; REVIEW OF ANSWER AND EMAIL CORRESPONDENCE FROM CLIENT; 02 PREPARED NOTICE OF REJECTION; E-FILED PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF 02 REJECTION .90 07 DATE : 1/05/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 07 REVIEW OF DEFENDANT'S ANSWER WITH COUNTERCLIAMS. SCAN AND EMAIL TO 07 CLIENT WITH INQUIRY. ATTENTION TO FILE RE: MOTION. .20 08 DATE : 1/05/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 08 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF NOTICE OF REJECTION OF ANSWER AND 08 COUNTERCLAIM. .20 (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 2 --- JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 09 DATE : 1/05/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 09 REVIEW OF STRING OF EMAILS SENT BY SAQ RE: TENANT'S OPENING DELAYED. .10 03 DATE : 1/06/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 03 EDITED AND REVISED NOTICE OF REJECTION; E-FILED SAME REJECTING ANSWER 03 E-FILED THIS MORNING .25 10 DATE : 1/06/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 10 REVIEW OF DEFENDAND'S AMENDED ANSWER. DICTTED NOTICE OF REJECTION. .20 11 DATE : 1/06/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 11 REVIW OF DEFENDANT'S THIRD FILING OF ANSWER. ATTENTION TO FILE. EMAIL 11 TO CLIENT. .25 12 DATE : 1/10/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 12 REVIEW OF 4TH AMENDMENT TO COMPLAINT. .10 13 DATE : 1/11/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 13 REVIEW OF NOTICE OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY .10 04 DATE : 1/17/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 04 TELEPHONE CALL WITH VIJAY RE: INFO NEEDED TO REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS .20 (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 3 --- JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 17 DATE : 1/18/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 17 PREPARED REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME .90 14 DATE : 1/19/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 14 REVIEW OF REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS. FORWARD TO CLIENT FOR REVIEW. .20 18 DATE : 1/19/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 18 FINALIZED RESPONSE TO COUNTERCLAIM AND E-FILED SAME .25 15 DATE : 1/27/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 15 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM DEFENDANT'S COUNSEL SEEKING TIME TO FILE AMENDED 15 ANSWER. ATTENTION TO FILE. .20 16 DATE : 1/27/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 16 REVIEW OF STIPULATION EXTENDING DEFENDANT'S TIME TO ANSWER. .10 19 DATE : 1/27/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 19 EMAIL WITH OPPOSING COUNSEL RE: REQUEST TO SERVE AMENDED ANSWER; .10 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 2.20 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $803.00 (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 4 --- JANUARY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 994848 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED JOSHUA NADELBACH = 2.60 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $910.00 _____ DISBURSEMENTS ____ DATE : 12/20/21 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $211.20 DATE : 12/27/21 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $102.30 DATE : 1/03/22 PROCESS SERVICE FEE SERVING OF DOCUMENTS $70.40 TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $2,096.90 BILLING PERIOD: 12/31/21 THROUGH 1/31/22 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 FEBRUARY 28,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 998274 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 01 DATE : 2/01/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM HOURS 01 ATTENTION TO FILE RE: STIPULATION EXTENDING DEFENDANT'S TIME TO FILE 01 ANSWER. .10 03 DATE : 2/02/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 03 EMAILS WITH OPPOSING COUNSEL RE: STIPULATION FOR AMENDED ANSWER .25 02 DATE : 2/11/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 02 REVIEW OF DEFENDANT'S ANSWER WITH COUNTERCLIAMS. FORWARD TO CLIENT. 02 ATTENTION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT. .20 04 DATE : 2/14/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 04 REVIEW OF DEFENDANTS' AMENDED ANSWER WITH COUNTERCLAIM COMPARING TO 04 COMPLAINT AND PRIOR FILED ANSWERS .40 05 DATE : 2/15/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 05 EMAILS WITH CLIENT RE: NEED FOR INFORMATION TO REPLY RESPONSE TO 05 COUNTERCLAIM .20 06 DATE : 2/17/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 06 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH VIJAY AND SOO RE: REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS. .30 07 DATE : 2/17/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 2 --- FEBRUARY 28,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 998274 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 07 DATE : 2/17/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 07 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM SOQ ATTACHMENT. .10 09 DATE : 2/17/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 09 CORRESPONDENCE WITH CLIENT RE: INFORMATION NEEDED FOR REPLY TO 09 COUNTERCLAIM; CONFERENCE CALL WITH SAQ AND VIJAY CONCERNING 09 DEFENDANTS' ANSWER; SEARCHED INSTAGRAM AND OTHER WEBSITES FOR PICTURES 09 OR STATEMENTS INDICATING WHEN PUNCH HOUSE OPENED 1.00 10 DATE : 2/18/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 10 PREPARED REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM TO AMENDED ANSWER FILED ON 2/11 .50 08 DATE : 2/22/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 08 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIMS. FORWARD TO CLIENT. .25 11 DATE : 2/22/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 11 EDITED AND REVISED DRAFT OF RESPONSE TO AMENDED ANSWER; E-FILED 11 RESPONSE TO COUNTERCLAIM .40 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .95 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $346.75 JOSHUA NADELBACH = 2.75 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $962.50 (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 3 --- FEBRUARY 28,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 998274 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $1,309.25 BILLING PERIOD: 1/31/22 THROUGH 2/31/22 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 MARCH 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 1990 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 02 DATE : 3/22/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS 02 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: MITIGATION OF DAMAGES .10 01 DATE : 3/28/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 01 REVIEW AND REPLY TO CLIENT RE: STATUS OF CASE AND MOTION. .10 03 DATE : 3/28/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 03 BEGAN DRAFTING MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGEMENT 2.00 04 DATE : 3/29/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 04 CONTINUED WRITING MEMORANDUM OF LAW DISMISSING DEFENSES 1.80 05 DATE : 3/31/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 05 CONTINUED PREPARING FIRST DRAFT OF MEMORANDUM OF LAW 2.00 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- JOSHUA NADELBACH = 5.90 @ $364/HR. TOTAL $2,147.60 DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .10 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $36.50 TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $2,184.10 BILLING PERIOD: 2/31/22 THROUGH 3/31/22 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 APRIL 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 5721 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 01 DATE : 4/01/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS 01 FINALIZED FIRST DRAFT OF MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY 01 JUDGMENT. 3.80 02 DATE : 4/05/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 02 BEGAN DRAFTING AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT 2.20 03 DATE : 4/07/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 03 FINALIZED FIRST DRAFT OF AFFIDAVIT; PREPARED AFFIRMATION, STATEMENT OF 03 FACTS 2.50 04 DATE : 4/08/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 04 EDITED PREPARED FINAL DRAFTS OF ALL MOTION PAPERS 2.80 05 DATE : 4/25/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 05 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF FIRST DRAFT OF SUPPORTING AFFIDAVITS, 05 FORWARD TO CLIENT. REVISED AFFIRMATION, MEMO OF LAW, STATEMENT OF 05 FACTS. 1.50 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- JOSHUA NADELBACH = 11.30 @ $364/HR. TOTAL $4,113.20 DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 1.50 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $547.50 (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 2 --- APRIL 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 5721 POSTED BY: IRI HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $4,660.70 BILLING PERIOD: 3/31/22 THROUGH 4/31/22 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 MAY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 9069 POSTED BY: CHR HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 02 DATE : 5/11/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS 02 EMAIL WITH CLIENT REGARDING STATUS OF AFFIDAVIT FOR FILING 02 SUMMARY JUDGMENT. .10 01 DATE : 5/16/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 01 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: ADVISEMENT OF RE-RENTAL. .10 03 DATE : 5/19/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 03 REVIEW OF EMAIL FROM CLIENT RE: EXECUTION OF RENEW LEASE WITH NEW 03 TENANT AND MITIGATION OF DAMAGES. REVIEW OF LEASE. .20 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- JOSHUA NADELBACH = .20 @ $350/HR. TOTAL $70.00 DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = .20 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $73.00 TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $143.00 BILLING PERIOD: 4/31/22 THROUGH 5/31/22 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 JUNE 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 12641 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 03 DATE : 6/02/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS 03 REVISED ARREARS IN AFFIDAVIT AS LANDLORD RE-RENTED; EDITED MEMORANDUM 03 OF LAW ; 1.50 01 DATE : 6/03/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 01 REVIEW OF .10 04 DATE : 6/03/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 04 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: BROKER'S INVOICE .10 05 DATE : 6/07/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 05 EDITED AND REVISED STATEMENT OF FACTS AND AFFIRMATION, AND COMPLETED 05 FINAL DRAFT OF ALL MOTION PAPERS 1.40 06 DATE : 6/08/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 06 PREPARED TABLE OF CONTENTS AND TABLE OF AUTHORITIES FOR MEMORANDUM OF 06 LAW PER COURT RULES 1.00 02 DATE : 6/16/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 02 REVIEW AND MODIFICATION OF SUPPORTING AFFIDAVIT, FORWARD TO CLIENT. 02 REVIEW AND REVISONS TO AFFIRMATION, MEMEO OF LAW AND STATEMENT OF 02 FACTS. 1.50 (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 2 --- JUNE 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 12641 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 07 DATE : 6/21/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 07 EDITED AND REVISED MOTION PAPERS PER EMAIL EDIT FROM CLIENT; EMAIL 07 WITH CLIENT RE: SAME .40 08 DATE : 6/23/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 08 EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: BACKUP FOR ELECTRIC CHARGES NEEDED FOR MOTION .10 09 DATE : 6/24/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 09 ATTENTION TO FILE RE: AMENDING MOTION TO INCLUDE ELECTRIC CHARGES 09 THROUGH MARCH 2022. .20 10 DATE : 6/24/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 10 REVIEW OF BACKUP CHARGES FOR ELECTRIC METER SENT BY CLIENT; COLLATED 10 EXHIBITS FOR FILING; EDITED AFFIDAVIT TO INCLUDE THE ELECTRIC FEES 10 FROM 12/21 - 4/22; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME 1.10 11 DATE : 6/27/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH 11 BOOKMARKED MEMORANDUM OF LAW PER COURT RULES; E-FILED MOTION PAPERS; 11 PREPARED RJI; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME .80 ----- T O T A L H O U R S ----- JOSHUA NADELBACH = 6.40 @ $364/HR. TOTAL $2,329.60 (CONTINUED) FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 --- PAGE 3 --- JUNE 30,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 12641 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 L/T# 161105/21 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED DAVID B. ROSENBAUM = 1.80 @ $365/HR. TOTAL $657.00 _____ DISBURSEMENTS ____ DATE : 6/27/22 NYSCEF FILING FEE FOR A NOTICE OF $158.60 MOTION TOTAL AMOUNT DUE $3,145.20 BILLING PERIOD: 5/31/22 THROUGH 6/31/22 PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO BORAH,GOLDSTEIN,ET.AL. AND INCLUDE YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER ON YOUR CHECK. NICOLEA WE ACCEPT ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS. YOU MAY CALL US OR VISIT https://quickclick.com/r/osrj8 TO PAY ONLINE. FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 05/04/2023 10:54 AM INDEX NO. 161105/2021 <> NYSCEF DOC. NO. 51 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/04/2023 BORAH, GOLDSTEIN, ALTSCHULER, NAHINS & GOIDEL, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 377 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10013 (212) 431-1300 JULY 31,2022 *** INVOICE RE-PRINT *** OPTION CODE-X INVOICE #: 16313 POSTED BY: STA HUDSON ASSOCIATES ACCOUNT #: HU1324 CODE: S 13 E 16TH STREET #400 CASE #: S07872 NEW YORK NY 10003 PREMISES : 19 W 21ST STREET APT : ** MATTER OF: FIFTH PARTNERS LLC V. PUNCH HOUSE FLATIR -- P R O F E S S I O N A L S E R V I C E S R E N D E R E D -- Principal Attorney..DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Lead Attorney.......DAVID B. ROSENBAUM Second Attorney.....NO ATTORNEY ASSIGNED 01 DATE : 7/11/22 - JOSHUA NADELBACH HOURS 01 REVIEW OF THE AFFIDAVIT AND AFFIRMATION FILED IN OPPOSITION TO 01 LANDLORD'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT; EMAIL WITH CLIENT RE: SAME; 01 BEGAN PREPARING REPLY PAPERS AND PULLING CASES CONCERNING FRAUDULENT 01 INDUCEMENT, THE ONLY "DEFENSE" 1.90 05 DATE : 7/11/22 - DAVID B. ROSENBAUM 05 REVIW OF DEFENDANT'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE AND FOR SUMMARY 05 JUDGMENT.