On April 19, 2023 a
Request for Judicial Intervention
was filed
involving a dispute between
In The Matter Of The Application Of The Metropolitan Transportation Authority Relative To Acquiring Fee Title In Real Property Required For The Second Avenue Subway Project - Phase 2, Contract 2 Block 1784, Lots 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 120, 122 And 128,
and
N A,
for Real Property - Condemnation
in the District Court of New York County.
Preview
INDEX NO. 451115/2023
1234256ÿ891ÿ4 ÿ6¼º½ÿ
212¿À¹Á
69ÿ
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 14 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/19/2023
5<³ÿ
7( ¥2¦¦9´³9´´´8ÿ
¶·¸¹º»º
ÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ
ÿ ÿ!"ÿÿ #$% ÿ ÿ &&' "ÿÿ !(ÿ!'(%ÿ& ÿ )*"ÿ
+69ÿ , % (ÿ%- ÿ.!/0) % ÿ.$& ÿ.$0%1! 2ÿ#!ÿ !%ÿ'& ÿ %ÿ$)ÿ!(ÿ %ÿ$ !2ÿ 3ÿ/!( ÿ&0$. ÿ1&ÿ ÿ$%%$.-ÿ$ÿ.$0%1! ÿ(1 (ÿ&- %2ÿ 45ÿ, %(*ÿ#$% ÿ
ÿÂÚÛÜÝÞßÿ
ÃÿÅÆÇÿÈÉÅÅÇÊÿËÌÿÅÆÇÿÍÎÎÏÐÑÉÅÐËÃÿËÌÿÅÆÇÿÈÇÅÊËÎËÏÐÅÉÃÿÒÊÉÃÓÎËÊÅÉÅÐËÃÿÍÔÅÆËÊÐÅÕÿÊÇÏÉÅÐÖÇÿÅËÿÉÑ×ÔÐÊÐÃØÿÌÇÇÿÅÐÅÏÇÿÐÃÿÊÇÉÏÿÎÊËÎÇÊÅÕÿÊÇ×ÔÐÊÇÙÿÌËÊÿÅÆÇ
ÍàÛÞáÛÿÚáâãÍäÿåæÝçÛÜÒÿèÿåéÍÚÛÿêëÿÜÝÞÒæÍÜÒÿê ÿ
âìÝÜíÿîïðñëÿìÝÒÚÿêòëÿêñëÿêóëÿêôëÿêïëÿêðëÿîêõëÿîêêÿÉÃÙÿîêðÿö÷ÛÛøë
ÉÓÿÓÉÐÙÿÎÊËÎÇÊÅÕÿÐÓÿÓÆËùÃÿËÃÿÅÆÇÿÑÔÊÊÇÃÅÿÒÉúÿÈÉÎÿËÌÿÅÆÇÿâËÊËÔØÆÿËÌÿÈÉÃÆÉÅÅÉÃëÿÜÐÅÕÿÉÃÙÿÚÅÉÅÇÿËÌÿÞÇùÿäËÊûü
6)$1 %1337&896 %1%1! (7&8ÿ :' ; ÿ4&&1; ÿ
<$;$1 &%<ÿ
ÿÃý ÿ
ÿÉ : ÿ1) ÿ#$% ÿ
# 3 $ %7&89 &0! %7&8ÿ
ÿ
6412ÿ98ÿ 69ÿ91ÿ+19 22 =ÿ - .>ÿ! )*ÿ! ÿ?!ÿ$ ÿ&0 .13*ÿ@- ( ÿ1 1.$% 2ÿ
9AA21 ÿ A61A9ÿ
ÿB'&1 &&ÿ, %1%*ÿ71 .)' &ÿ.!(0!($%1! &ÿ0$(% (&-10&ÿCC&ÿCC6&ÿ %.28ÿ ÿ! % &% ÿ
ÿ! %($.%ÿ DEFGHÿJKÿLMNONÿPONÿQMRSTONUÿVUTNOÿLMNÿPWNÿXKÿYZ[ÿQX\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿ
ÿ &'($ . ÿ7@- ( ÿ1 &'($ . ÿ.!/0$ *ÿ1&ÿ$ÿ0$(%*ÿ . 0%ÿ$(?1%($%1! 8ÿ ^_F`a^EDa_bÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklm^noÿ
ÿÿ71 .)' &ÿ&$) &ÿ$ ÿ ;!%1$?) ÿ1 &%('/ %&8ÿ pXOÿqUQXULNrLNTÿsPLOR\XURPSÿPQLRXUr[ÿVrNÿLMNÿqUQXULNrLNTÿtRuXOQNÿvwJÿxfejyz{oÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ!// (.1$)ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ12ÿ+19+216}ÿ 50 .13*ÿ-!@ÿ/$ *ÿ0(!0 (%1 &ÿ%- ÿ$00)1.$%1! ÿ1 .)' &"ÿÿ
DEFGHÿpXOÿ~X\\NOQRPSÿtRuRrRXUÿPrrRWU\NULÿONVNrLrÿ]VOrVPULÿLXÿÿ~vvÿoxT{[ÿ ÿ! / $%1! ÿ
QX\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿhE^^G`ha_bÿeaaiaEDÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklmhnoÿ ÿ!(%;$; ÿ!( .)!&'( ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿ ÿ &1 %1$)ÿ ÿ!// (.1$)ÿ
69165ÿ 6(!0 (%*ÿ4 ( &&"ÿÿ
ÿ4 ')%ÿ5'(ÿ¥1¥!(&ÿ4.% DEFGHÿpXOÿsXOLWPWNÿpXONQSXrVONÿPQLRXUrÿRUuXSuRUWÿPÿXUNÿLXÿKXVOKP\RS|[ÿ
ÿ4&? &%!& ÿ XUNOXQQV]RNTÿONrRTNULRPSÿ]OX]NOL|ÿXOÿXUNOXQQV]RNTÿQXUTX\RURV\[ÿ
ÿ, ¥1(! / %$)ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ QX\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿE`GhbEif`Gÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklmnoÿ
ÿ 1.$)ÿ# %$)ÿ!(ÿ6! 1$%(1.ÿ$)0($.%1. ÿ ÿ6$(%1%1! ÿ
ÿ!%!(ÿµ -1.) ÿ DEFGHÿ~X\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿ_`FaFaEDÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklmnoÿ
ÿ6(! '.%&ÿC1$?1)1%*ÿ7r]NQRK|8"
ÿÿ ÿ$ÿ (%1!($(1ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿ 5 .%1! "ÿB)!.>"ÿC!%"ÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ ;)1; . ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ ÿ$ÿ!( .)!&'( ÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ6(!3 &&1! $)ÿ$)0($.%1. ÿ7&0 .13*8"ÿÿ ÿ%- (ÿ $)ÿ6(!0 (%*ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ!(%7&0 .13*8"ÿÿ9621ÿA66215ÿ
5+2 ÿ+19 22 =5ÿ ÿ (%131.$% ÿ!3ÿ .!(0!($%1! 9#1&&!)'%1! ÿ& ÿDEFGÿ1 ÿ9AA21 ÿ& .%1! ÿ
ÿ-1) <6$( %ÿ5 .'(1%*ÿ4.%ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ 4&&1&% ÿ 0(! '.%1! ÿÿÿÿ 5'((!;$.*ÿ4;( / %ÿ ÿ,/ (; .*ÿ 1.$)ÿ( $%/ %ÿ
ÿ6Cÿ4(%1.) ÿÿÿ4(?1%($%1! ÿ & ÿDEFGÿ1 ÿ9AA21 ÿ& .%1! ÿ ÿ$? $&ÿ!(0'&ÿ
ÿ6Cÿ4(%1.) ÿÿÿ6(!. 1 ;ÿ$;$1 &%ÿ$ÿB! *ÿ!(ÿ331. (ÿ ÿC!.$)ÿ!'(%ÿ400 $)ÿ
ÿ,) .%1! ÿC$@ÿ ÿÿÿ
ÿ,%( / ÿ1&>ÿ6(!% .%1! ÿ( (ÿ ÿ$/ ÿ-$ ; 95 ÿ# &1; $%1! ÿ-$ ; ÿ
ÿCÿ4(%1.) ÿ2ÿÿ¡¢£ÿ¤ÿ ÿ61&%!)ÿ6 (/1%ÿ ¥!.$%1! ÿ $(1 ;ÿ
ÿCÿ4(%1.) ÿ¦ÿÿ5 ÿ33 (ÿ! 31 / %ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿ ÿ 1%1$)ÿ ÿ ¥1 @ÿ ÿ5$) ÿ!(ÿ1 $ . ÿ!3ÿ )1;1!'&9!%<3!(<6(!31%ÿ6(!0 (%*ÿ
ÿCÿ4(%1.) ÿ¦ÿ7§'$( 1$ &-108ÿ ÿ%- (ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ %$)ÿ*;1 ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ50 .1$)ÿ6(!. 1 ;ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿÿ
5ÿ6645ÿ98ÿ 69ÿ91ÿ+19 22 =ÿ 4 &@ (ÿ,5ÿ!(ÿÿ3!(ÿ ¥ (*ÿ̈' &%1! ÿ$ ÿ % (ÿ$ 1%1! $)ÿ1 3!(/$%1! ÿ@- ( ÿ1 1.$% 2ÿ
}25ÿ 9ÿ ÿ
$&ÿ$ÿ&'//! &ÿ$ ÿ.!/0)$1 %ÿ!(ÿ&'//! &ÿ@1%-ÿ !%1. ÿ? ÿ31) ©ÿ ÿ ÿ 3ÿ* &ÿ $% ÿ31) "ÿ ÿ
$&ÿ$ÿ&'//! &ÿ$ ÿ.!/0)$1 %ÿ!(ÿ&'//! &ÿ@1%-ÿ !%1. ÿ? ÿ& (¥ ©ÿ ÿ ÿ 3ÿ* &ÿ $% ÿ& (¥ "ÿ ÿ
&ÿ%-1&ÿ$.%1! 90(!. 1 ;ÿ? 1 ;ÿ31) ÿ0!&%<ª' ;/ %©ÿ ÿ ÿ 3ÿ* &ÿª' ;/ %ÿ $% "ÿÿ
6412ÿ98ÿ4 ÿ621269ÿ - .>ÿ! ÿ?!ÿ! )*ÿ$ ÿ % (ÿ$ 1%1! $)ÿ1 3!(/$%1! ÿ@- ( ÿ1 1.$% 2ÿ
ÿ«¬ÿ®¯°±£¯°ÿ
ÿ,%( / ÿ1&>ÿ6(!% .%1! ÿ( (ÿ400)1.$%1! ÿ
ÿ!% ÿ!3ÿ &&' 9 (%131.$% ÿ!3ÿ $ 1 &&ÿ
ÿ!%1. ÿ!3ÿ 1.$)ÿ# %$)ÿ!(ÿ6! 1$%(1.ÿ$)0($.%1. ÿ #$% ÿ &&' ÿ:!1 "ÿÿ
ÿ!%1. ÿ!3ÿ!%1! ÿ )1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÿ %'( ÿ#$% "ÿÿ
ÿ!%1. ÿ!3ÿ6 %1%1! ÿ ÉÅÐËÃÿËÊÙÇÊÿ %'( ÿ#$% "ÿõó
)1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÑËÃÙÇþÃ ý
ê
êýêõ
ê
òÿ
ÿ( (ÿ%!ÿ5-!@ÿ$'& ÿ )1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÿ %'( ÿ#$% "ÿÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ,ÿ6$(% ÿ400)1.$%1! ÿ )1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÿ ÿ
ÿ6$(%1%1! ÿ5 %%) / %ÿ! 3 ( . ÿ
ÿ6!!(ÿ6 (&! ÿ400)1.$%1! ÿ
ÿ ¨' &%ÿ3!(ÿ6( )1/1 $(*ÿ! 3 ( . ÿ
ÿ &1 %1$)ÿ!(%;$; ÿ!( .)!&'( ÿ5 %%) / %ÿ! 3 ( . ÿ
ÿ²(1%ÿ!3ÿ$? $&ÿ!(0'&ÿ
ÿ%- (ÿ7&0 .13*8"ÿÿ
1 of 2
INDEX NO. 451115/2023
0123415ÿ73818ÿ 9 ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿRECEIVED
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 14 ÿÿ ÿÿNYSCEF:
ÿ!"ÿ 04/19/2023
ÿ ÿ#ÿÿ$ ÿ#ÿÿ %ÿ%ÿ0&'ÿ3551(5)*ÿ+)78,-./30ÿ
7123ÿ44563ÿ '7839:7123ÿ(;<=3>ÿ 7?;>5ÿ &;8@3ÿ+4Aÿ1224@7380ÿ 036154?72B4Cÿ5?ÿ4725175ÿD123ÿ
ÿ}ÿ
~ÿÿÿÿÿ~ÿÿÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ
~ÿÿÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
E304'18ÿ FGHÿJKHLMNOÿPMLQGRLÿKSÿKLLGHSNTUÿVQNVWÿLQNÿXYSZ[NJ\ÿ]G^ÿKS_ÿNSLNHÿLQNÿJKHLTÒÿK__HNOOÿ#%ÿ !ÿÿÿÿ%ÿ#ÿ# ÿ
ÿ ÿ#ÿÿ$ ÿ#ÿÿ %ÿ%ÿ0&'ÿ3551(5)*ÿ+)78,-./30ÿ
)7,E1>5432ÿ 355?>73e2ÿ178ÿ)7>3C>3237538ÿ2454@1752ÿ '22;3ÿ&?4738ÿ '72;>17D3ÿ71>>43>2ÿ
03Cÿ9 ÿ#ÿÿÿÿÿ ÿÿ%ÿ ÿ#ÿ#ÿ# ÿ Òÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ#%ÿÿ ÿ%ÿ ÿÿ%ÿ ÿ
# ÿÿÿÿabÿ# ÿÿÿÿ #ÿ#ÿ# ÿJKHLTÒÿ ÿ#%ÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ%ÿ ÿ ÿ
ÿcÿ#ÿ# ÿdÿ !ÿfÿ ÿ ÿ##!ÿ
ghÿ ~~ÿ¡ÿ¢
ÿiadhÿÿ ÿ¢ÿ£ÿ¤¥¦ÿ§¨¨©
ÿªÿ«ÿ
¬ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ®¯¯°ÿ±¯«
ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
ÿghÿ
iadhÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ
'ÿ3nn'0*ÿ)(510ÿ4o1ÿE1(324pÿqnÿE10&)0pÿ4o34rÿ)Eq(ÿ'(nq0*34'q(ÿ3(5ÿs12'1nrÿ4o101ÿ301ÿ(qÿq4o10ÿ0123415ÿ374'q(8ÿq0ÿE0q7115'(t8rÿ
1u71E4ÿ38ÿ(q415ÿ3sqv1rÿ(q0ÿo38ÿ3ÿ01w)184ÿnq0ÿ&)5'7'32ÿ'(410v1(4'q(ÿs11(ÿE01v'q)82pÿn'215ÿ'(ÿ4o'8ÿ374'q(ÿq0ÿE0q7115'(txÿ
|hÿyyyyy²y³yyµ́y¶y´y·y²y·y¸yyyyyÿ yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyÿ
ÿ lb ÿ
yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy·y¹yºy»y¸y¶y³yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyÿ yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy¼½
yyy¾¾½
yyy¿Àÿ
yyÂyÃÿyÄÅÅÆ
yyyy½yÇÈ
yyÉÊ
yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyÿ
ÿ
z ÿib ÿg !ÿ {ÿgÿ
2 of 2
Document Filed Date
April 19, 2023
Case Filing Date
April 19, 2023
Category
Real Property - Condemnation
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
INDEX NO. 451115/2023 1234256ÿ891ÿ4 ÿ6¼º½ÿ 212¿À¹Á 69ÿ NYSCEF DOC. NO. 14 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/19/2023 5<³ÿ 7( ¥2¦¦9´³9´´´8ÿ ¶·¸¹º»º ÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ!"ÿÿ #$% ÿ ÿ &&' "ÿÿ !(ÿ!'(%ÿ& ÿ )*"ÿ +69ÿ , % (ÿ%- ÿ.!/0) % ÿ.$& ÿ.$0%1! 2ÿ#!ÿ !%ÿ'& ÿ %ÿ$)ÿ!(ÿ %ÿ$ !2ÿ 3ÿ/!( ÿ&0$. ÿ1&ÿ ÿ$%%$.-ÿ$ÿ.$0%1! ÿ(1 (ÿ&- %2ÿ 45ÿ, %(*ÿ#$% ÿ ÿÂÚÛÜÝÞßÿ ÃÿÅÆÇÿÈÉÅÅÇÊÿËÌÿÅÆÇÿÍÎÎÏÐÑÉÅÐËÃÿËÌÿÅÆÇÿÈÇÅÊËÎËÏÐÅÉÃÿÒÊÉÃÓÎËÊÅÉÅÐËÃÿÍÔÅÆËÊÐÅÕÿÊÇÏÉÅÐÖÇÿÅËÿÉÑ×ÔÐÊÐÃØÿÌÇÇÿÅÐÅÏÇÿÐÃÿÊÇÉÏÿÎÊËÎÇÊÅÕÿÊÇ×ÔÐÊÇÙÿÌËÊÿÅÆÇ ÍàÛÞáÛÿÚáâãÍäÿåæÝçÛÜÒÿèÿåéÍÚÛÿêëÿÜÝÞÒæÍÜÒÿê ÿ âìÝÜíÿîïðñëÿìÝÒÚÿêòëÿêñëÿêóëÿêôëÿêïëÿêðëÿîêõëÿîêêÿÉÃÙÿîêðÿö÷ÛÛøë ÉÓÿÓÉÐÙÿÎÊËÎÇÊÅÕÿÐÓÿÓÆËùÃÿËÃÿÅÆÇÿÑÔÊÊÇÃÅÿÒÉúÿÈÉÎÿËÌÿÅÆÇÿâËÊËÔØÆÿËÌÿÈÉÃÆÉÅÅÉÃëÿÜÐÅÕÿÉÃÙÿÚÅÉÅÇÿËÌÿÞÇùÿäËÊûü 6)$1 %1337&896 %1%1! (7&8ÿ :' ; ÿ4&&1; ÿ <$;$1 &%<ÿ ÿÃý ÿ ÿÉ : ÿ1) ÿ#$% ÿ # 3 $ %7&89 &0! %7&8ÿ ÿ 6412ÿ98ÿ 69ÿ91ÿ+19 22 =ÿ - .>ÿ! )*ÿ! ÿ?!ÿ$ ÿ&0 .13*ÿ@- ( ÿ1 1.$% 2ÿ 9AA21 ÿ A61A9ÿ ÿB'&1 &&ÿ, %1%*ÿ71 .)' &ÿ.!(0!($%1! &ÿ0$(% (&-10&ÿCC&ÿCC6&ÿ %.28ÿ ÿ! % &% ÿ ÿ! %($.%ÿ DEFGHÿJKÿLMNONÿPONÿQMRSTONUÿVUTNOÿLMNÿPWNÿXKÿYZ[ÿQX\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿ ÿ &'($ . ÿ7@- ( ÿ1 &'($ . ÿ.!/0$ *ÿ1&ÿ$ÿ0$(%*ÿ . 0%ÿ$(?1%($%1! 8ÿ ^_F`a^EDa_bÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklm^noÿ ÿÿ71 .)' &ÿ&$) &ÿ$ ÿ ;!%1$?) ÿ1 &%('/ %&8ÿ pXOÿqUQXULNrLNTÿsPLOR\XURPSÿPQLRXUr[ÿVrNÿLMNÿqUQXULNrLNTÿtRuXOQNÿvwJÿxfejyz{oÿ ÿ%- (ÿ!// (.1$)ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ12ÿ+19+216}ÿ 50 .13*ÿ-!@ÿ/$ *ÿ0(!0 (%1 &ÿ%- ÿ$00)1.$%1! ÿ1 .)' &"ÿÿ DEFGHÿpXOÿ~X\\NOQRPSÿtRuRrRXUÿPrrRWU\NULÿONVNrLrÿ]VOrVPULÿLXÿÿ~vvÿoxT{[ÿ ÿ! / $%1! ÿ QX\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿhE^^G`ha_bÿeaaiaEDÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklmhnoÿ ÿ!(%;$; ÿ!( .)!&'( ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿ ÿ &1 %1$)ÿ ÿ!// (.1$)ÿ 69165ÿ 6(!0 (%*ÿ4 ( &&"ÿÿ ÿ4 ')%ÿ5'(ÿ¥1¥!(&ÿ4.% DEFGHÿpXOÿsXOLWPWNÿpXONQSXrVONÿPQLRXUrÿRUuXSuRUWÿPÿXUNÿLXÿKXVOKP\RS|[ÿ ÿ4&? &%!& ÿ XUNOXQQV]RNTÿONrRTNULRPSÿ]OX]NOL|ÿXOÿXUNOXQQV]RNTÿQXUTX\RURV\[ÿ ÿ, ¥1(! / %$)ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ QX\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿE`GhbEif`Gÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklmnoÿ ÿ 1.$)ÿ# %$)ÿ!(ÿ6! 1$%(1.ÿ$)0($.%1. ÿ ÿ6$(%1%1! ÿ ÿ!%!(ÿµ -1.) ÿ DEFGHÿ~X\]SNLNÿPUTÿPLLPQMÿLMNÿ_`FaFaEDÿ̀daÿ_eeGDef^ÿgfhijklmnoÿ ÿ6(! '.%&ÿC1$?1)1%*ÿ7r]NQRK|8" ÿÿ ÿ$ÿ (%1!($(1ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿ 5 .%1! "ÿB)!.>"ÿC!%"ÿ ÿ%- (ÿ ;)1; . ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ ÿ$ÿ!( .)!&'( ÿ ÿ%- (ÿ6(!3 &&1! $)ÿ$)0($.%1. ÿ7&0 .13*8"ÿÿ ÿ%- (ÿ $)ÿ6(!0 (%*ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ ÿ%- (ÿ!(%7&0 .13*8"ÿÿ9621ÿA66215ÿ 5+2 ÿ+19 22 =5ÿ ÿ (%131.$% ÿ!3ÿ .!(0!($%1! 9#1&&!)'%1! ÿ& ÿDEFGÿ1 ÿ9AA21 ÿ& .%1! ÿ ÿ-1) <6$( %ÿ5 .'(1%*ÿ4.%ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ 4&&1&% ÿ 0(! '.%1! ÿÿÿÿ 5'((!;$.*ÿ4;( / %ÿ ÿ,/ (; .*ÿ 1.$)ÿ( $%/ %ÿ ÿ6Cÿ4(%1.) ÿÿÿ4(?1%($%1! ÿ & ÿDEFGÿ1 ÿ9AA21 ÿ& .%1! ÿ ÿ$? $&ÿ!(0'&ÿ ÿ6Cÿ4(%1.) ÿÿÿ6(!. 1 ;ÿ$;$1 &%ÿ$ÿB! *ÿ!(ÿ331. (ÿ ÿC!.$)ÿ!'(%ÿ400 $)ÿ ÿ,) .%1! ÿC$@ÿ ÿÿÿ ÿ,%( / ÿ1&>ÿ6(!% .%1! ÿ( (ÿ ÿ$/ ÿ-$ ; 95 ÿ# &1; $%1! ÿ-$ ; ÿ ÿCÿ4(%1.) ÿ2ÿÿ¡¢£ÿ¤ÿ ÿ61&%!)ÿ6 (/1%ÿ ¥!.$%1! ÿ $(1 ;ÿ ÿCÿ4(%1.) ÿ¦ÿÿ5 ÿ33 (ÿ! 31 / %ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿ ÿ 1%1$)ÿ ÿ ¥1 @ÿ ÿ5$) ÿ!(ÿ1 $ . ÿ!3ÿ )1;1!'&9!%<3!(<6(!31%ÿ6(!0 (%*ÿ ÿCÿ4(%1.) ÿ¦ÿ7§'$( 1$ &-108ÿ ÿ%- (ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ ÿ%- (ÿ %$)ÿ*;1 ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿ ÿ%- (ÿ50 .1$)ÿ6(!. 1 ;ÿ7r]NQRK|8"ÿÿÿ 5ÿ6645ÿ98ÿ 69ÿ91ÿ+19 22 =ÿ 4 &@ (ÿ,5ÿ!(ÿÿ3!(ÿ ¥ (*ÿ̈' &%1! ÿ$ ÿ % (ÿ$ 1%1! $)ÿ1 3!(/$%1! ÿ@- ( ÿ1 1.$% 2ÿ }25ÿ 9ÿ ÿ $&ÿ$ÿ&'//! &ÿ$ ÿ.!/0)$1 %ÿ!(ÿ&'//! &ÿ@1%-ÿ !%1. ÿ? ÿ31) ©ÿ ÿ ÿ 3ÿ* &ÿ $% ÿ31) "ÿ ÿ $&ÿ$ÿ&'//! &ÿ$ ÿ.!/0)$1 %ÿ!(ÿ&'//! &ÿ@1%-ÿ !%1. ÿ? ÿ& (¥ ©ÿ ÿ ÿ 3ÿ* &ÿ $% ÿ& (¥ "ÿ ÿ &ÿ%-1&ÿ$.%1! 90(!. 1 ;ÿ? 1 ;ÿ31) ÿ0!&%<ª' ;/ %©ÿ ÿ ÿ 3ÿ* &ÿª' ;/ %ÿ $% "ÿÿ 6412ÿ98ÿ4 ÿ621269ÿ - .>ÿ! ÿ?!ÿ! )*ÿ$ ÿ % (ÿ$ 1%1! $)ÿ1 3!(/$%1! ÿ@- ( ÿ1 1.$% 2ÿ ÿ«¬ÿ®¯°±£¯°ÿ ÿ,%( / ÿ1&>ÿ6(!% .%1! ÿ( (ÿ400)1.$%1! ÿ ÿ!% ÿ!3ÿ &&' 9 (%131.$% ÿ!3ÿ $ 1 &&ÿ ÿ!%1. ÿ!3ÿ 1.$)ÿ# %$)ÿ!(ÿ6! 1$%(1.ÿ$)0($.%1. ÿ #$% ÿ &&' ÿ:!1 "ÿÿ ÿ!%1. ÿ!3ÿ!%1! ÿ )1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÿ %'( ÿ#$% "ÿÿ ÿ!%1. ÿ!3ÿ6 %1%1! ÿ ÉÅÐËÃÿËÊÙÇÊÿ %'( ÿ#$% "ÿõó )1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÑËÃÙÇþà ý ê êýêõ ê òÿ ÿ( (ÿ%!ÿ5-!@ÿ$'& ÿ )1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÿ %'( ÿ#$% "ÿÿ ÿ%- (ÿ,ÿ6$(% ÿ400)1.$%1! ÿ )1 3ÿ ¨' &% "ÿÿ ÿ ÿ6$(%1%1! ÿ5 %%) / %ÿ! 3 ( . ÿ ÿ6!!(ÿ6 (&! ÿ400)1.$%1! ÿ ÿ ¨' &%ÿ3!(ÿ6( )1/1 $(*ÿ! 3 ( . ÿ ÿ &1 %1$)ÿ!(%;$; ÿ!( .)!&'( ÿ5 %%) / %ÿ! 3 ( . ÿ ÿ²(1%ÿ!3ÿ$? $&ÿ!(0'&ÿ ÿ%- (ÿ7&0 .13*8"ÿÿ 1 of 2 INDEX NO. 451115/2023 0123415ÿ73818ÿ 9 ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿRECEIVED NYSCEF DOC. NO. 14 ÿÿ ÿÿNYSCEF: ÿ!"ÿ 04/19/2023 ÿ ÿ#ÿÿ$ ÿ#ÿÿ %ÿ%ÿ0&'ÿ3551(5)*ÿ+)78,-./30ÿ 7123ÿ44563ÿ '7839:7123ÿ(;<=3>ÿ 7?;>5ÿ &;8@3ÿ+4Aÿ1224@7380ÿ 036154?72B4Cÿ5?ÿ4725175ÿD123ÿ ÿ}ÿ ~ÿÿÿÿÿ~ÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ ~ÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ E304'18ÿ FGHÿJKHLMNOÿPMLQGRLÿKSÿKLLGHSNTUÿVQNVWÿLQNÿXYSZ[NJ\ÿ]G^ÿKS_ÿNSLNHÿLQNÿJKHLTÒÿK__HNOOÿ#%ÿ !ÿÿÿÿ%ÿ#ÿ# ÿ ÿ ÿ#ÿÿ$ ÿ#ÿÿ %ÿ%ÿ0&'ÿ3551(5)*ÿ+)78,-./30ÿ )7,E1>5432ÿ 355?>73e2ÿ178ÿ)7>3C>3237538ÿ2454@1752ÿ '22;3ÿ&?4738ÿ '72;>17D3ÿ71>>43>2ÿ 03Cÿ9 ÿ#ÿÿÿÿÿ ÿÿ%ÿ ÿ#ÿ#ÿ# ÿ Òÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ#%ÿÿ ÿ%ÿ ÿÿ%ÿ ÿ # ÿÿÿÿabÿ# ÿÿÿÿ #ÿ#ÿ# ÿJKHLTÒÿ ÿ#%ÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ%ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿcÿ#ÿ# ÿdÿ !ÿfÿ ÿ ÿ##!ÿ ghÿ ~~ÿ¡ÿ¢ ÿiadhÿÿ ÿ¢ÿ£ÿ¤¥¦ÿ§¨¨© ÿªÿ«ÿ ¬ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ®¯¯°ÿ±¯« ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ ÿghÿ iadhÿ ÿ ÿ ÿjklÿ ÿgmÿÿ 'ÿ3nn'0*ÿ)(510ÿ4o1ÿE1(324pÿqnÿE10&)0pÿ4o34rÿ)Eq(ÿ'(nq0*34'q(ÿ3(5ÿs12'1nrÿ4o101ÿ301ÿ(qÿq4o10ÿ0123415ÿ374'q(8ÿq0ÿE0q7115'(t8rÿ 1u71E4ÿ38ÿ(q415ÿ3sqv1rÿ(q0ÿo38ÿ3ÿ01w)184ÿnq0ÿ&)5'7'32ÿ'(410v1(4'q(ÿs11(ÿE01v'q)82pÿn'215ÿ'(ÿ4o'8ÿ374'q(ÿq0ÿE0q7115'(txÿ |hÿyyyyy²y³yyµ́y¶y´y·y²y·y¸yyyyyÿ yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyÿ ÿ lb ÿ yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy·y¹yºy»y¸y¶y³yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyÿ yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy¼½ yyy¾¾½ yyy¿Àÿ yyÂyÃÿyÄÅÅÆ yyyy½yÇÈ yyÉÊ yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyÿ ÿ z ÿib ÿg !ÿ {ÿgÿ 2 of 2