Preview
DAK:ik IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
97-605 20™ JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO. 00-120 CA
(00-1544 CA - consolidated)
into main case)
SALLY SIMON, as Personal
Representative of the Estate
of Michael Simon,
Plaintiff,
vs.
MARK ASPERILLA, M.D.,
MARK ASPERILLA, M.D., P.A.,
a Florida corporation, DALE
GREENBERG, M.D., RONALD
CONSTINE, M.D., LEVY BAKER
CONSTINE & GREENBERG, M.D.
P.A., a Florida corporation, SAMUEL
ESTEPA, M.D., PRIMARY CARE
PHYSICIANS, INC., a Florida corpora-
tion, NASIR KHALIDI, M.D., NASIR
KHALIDI, M.D., & SAKINA KHALIDI, M.D.,
P.A., a Florida corporation, and CONRAD
EPPING KOERPER, M.D., COLEMAN &
CASTELLON, M.D., P.A., a/k/a CHARLOTTE
RADIOLOGY GROUP, and BON SECOURS-
ST. JOSEPH HOSPITAL, a Florida corporation,
Defendants.
/
RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE OF
DEFENDANT, COLEMAN & CASTELLON, M.D., P.A. IMAGED 7
Charlotte County Clerk
C1237375 Date : 01/23/04 - 14:16:02 id: 14
Case#: 00000120CA Hill 0008
IAN
KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7000 SW 97" AVE., #210, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791Simon v. Asperilla, M.D., etal., Case No. 00-120-CA.
COMES NOW, the Plaintiff, SALLY SIMON, as Personal Representative of the
Estate of Michael Simon, by and through her undersigned attorney, and in response to the
Request To Produce propounded to said party by Defendant, COLEMAN & CASTELLON,
M.D., P.A., on October 30, 2000, states as follows:
41. Response to Request No. 1, previously forwarded on or about December 6,
2000, at the time of responding to Request to Produce of Defendant, Bon-Secours.
2. Response to Request No. 2, none.
3. Response to Request No. 3, photographs in Plaintiff's possession are
available for inspection at a mutually convenient date and time.
4. Response to Request No. 4, none other than any presuit responses that may
have been received by Plaintiffs counsel, copies of which would certainly be in the
possession of defense counsel.
5. Response to Request No. 5, objection, none as to the Plaintiff, and objection,
work product, if there are any notes concerning any oral conversations that any person in
the employ of Plaintiffs counsel may have had with any agent, servant and/or employee
of this Defendant.
6. Response to Request No. 6, see response to No. 3 above.
7. Response to Request No. 7, see response to No. 1 above.
8. Response to Request No. 8, see response to No. 1 above.
9. Response to Request No. 9, attached.
10. Response to Request No. 10, attached.
KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7000 SW 97" AVE., #210, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791Simon v. Asperilla, M.D., etal., Case No. 00-120-CA
11. | Response to Request No. 11, none.
| HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing, together with
copies of requested documentation, were mailed this 18 day of January, 2001, to:
CLIFFORDL. SOMERS, ESQ., BARR MURMAN TONELLI SLOTHER & SLEET, Attorneys
for Defendant, Coleman 7 Castellon, M.D., P.A., 201 E. Kennedy Blvd., #1750, Tampa, FL
33602; and true and correct copies of the foregoing Response were furnished to all
counsel listed on attached certificate of service.
KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A.
Attorneys for Plaintiff
7000 S.W. 97th Avenue, Suite 210
Miami, FL 33173
305 595-6791 - Dade
305 595-5400 - Fascimile
i
DENNIS A. KOLTUN
Fla. Bar No. 163040
KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7000 SW 97" AVE., #210, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
RE: SIMON V. ASPERILLA, M.D., ETAL. - CASE NO. 00-120 CA
pF HEREBY CERTIFY that true and correct copies of the foregoing were mailed this
day of January, 2001, to:
THOMAS A. CULMO, ESQ.
Culmo & Culmo, P.A.
Co-Counsel for Plaintiff
2400 South Dixie Highway, #100
Miami, FL 33133
KIMBERLY J. LEE, ESQ.
Wicker, Smith, Tutan, O'Hara,
McCoy, Graham & Ford, P.A.
Attorneys for Defs, Dr. Khalidi
P.O. Box 2152
100 North Tampa Street, #3650
Tampa, FL 33601-2152
BENITO H. DIAZ, ESQ.
Diaz & Morel-Saruski
Attorneys for Defs., Samuel Estepa, MD
& Primary Care Phys. Organization
2912 Douglas Road
Coral Gables, FL 33134
LYNN H. GROSECLOSE, ESQ.
Thompson Goadis Thompson
Groseclose & Richardson, P.A.
Attorneys for Defs., Asperilla, MD
100 Wallace Avenue, #240
Sarasota, FL 34237
CLIFFORD L. SOMERS, ESQ.
Barr Murman & Tonelli, P.A.
Attorneys for Defendant., Coleman and
Castellon, P.A.
201 East Kennedy Blvd., #1750 & 2000
Tampa, FL 33602
CRAIG R. STEVENS, ESQ.
George, Hart z, Lundeen & Fulmer
Attorneys for Defs Greenberg, Constine,
& Levy, Baker, Constine & Greenberg
2000 Main Street, #402
Fort Myers, FL 33901
RAYMOND REISER, ESQ.
REISER & ALLISON, P.A.
Attorneys for Defendant., Koerper
1 Southeast Third Avenue, #1860
Miami, FL 33131
KELLY JO SMITH, ESQ.
Hahn, Morgan & Lamb, P.A.
Attorneys for Defendant., Bon Secours
2701 N. Rocky Point Drive, #410
Tampa, FL 33607-5917
KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A.
Attorneys for Plaintiff
7101 S.W. 102 Avenue
Miami, FL 33173
305 595-6791 - Dade
305 595-5400 - Facsimile
Waris fe
DENNIS A. KOLTUN
FBN: 163040RESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 9
Marriage CertificateWARE HE
APPLICATION NO _ FLORIDA STATE FILE NO.
a 7 ern TUB TT gi soe
Mac we
ot a MICHBEL GARY SIMON -
PERSONAL 161 ererBbave. ON Sit. tat areas “
yd Port Charlotte Charlotte Florida 33952 | 525-42 i 39
5 = 7 pepcete wetars TOWWTO GH wr nov suse want ezauray
DATA | FIC AS MASH ERUED RY avec eat SRE SERA eae
ze! divorce _sonce ua asncueens 12-8-80 N.Y.
g kine v vitiss ioe tot, T Bower name e ilatcr, 3 Rice
: toa :
Fevane | 3 | eS PERSO _COOPER i i Gane.
te) = Jes Evade ave (osm Fae} Va pate oF are TERE
PERSONA: | me ! etexe . : '
CP inate - x x: Z 395 {11-27-47 33
2 FON OF TO ath TF @AEVIGUSEY MARRIED _-. 1 FATE 4 Bin SNOT NUR a waMeCGuNTeY
pata | OD, maariace APRS ENDED SV ieecns ouazm PAB DATE LAS MAMATE NOE
it sy Th GWOREE BR AKU LM ENT HL . pel.
—_———| 6 " x
= J GYR ANG ESCE AND BF
s $
| a
AFFIDAVIT ae
OF FEMALE!
AND MALE |
ae Cente ae The
MIAIR ASE ACCT
ter
Sate
3c eaaye
37 $4 BES IN OP EEA,
Hp &. CHEATD BY FELONY
ro | ae
eA
see7 7 Minti
Solomon Agin
© Rabbi, Temple Beth-El
HL OREBO.BOx OTD
ot
MARRY
1 ey Pewee fy count syek Le
Cape Corai,FL
This licensa valid uniess seal ot Clerk, AUDIT .
cuit sr County Court, appears thereon. UDIT CONTROL NO. t
i
.
Ceeteg ssat
Maz,
A
* 4p,"
0. AL
“eeogsasd tltRESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 10
Death CertificateOFFICE of VITAL STATISTICS
CERTIFIED COPY
i
We
Gee
CERTIFICATE OF OEATH
"FLORIDA : ~7
Tage TTT TH
MICHAEL Al = : ® MA)
GEREN
BRE BF GAIT oa ap =
AUGUST 21, 1998 : “Bb Tea
BE a Bac or ea won Om wo T inte ace fg Sh 2g COM,
MAY, 25,1942 BROOKLYN): NEW YORK
BF DEN a Be fs OT ;
HOSPINAL X. eqmuant! = CROAoineN’ —"DOR.
Ahm regis REE omnes ford or
Rone SawGRIrt “MEMORIAL HOSPITAL — :
o EEE VEU OCVPAIO OF BURMERSANOHISTIN i
‘QUNER/OPERATOR MARINE SERVICES ED. SARAH COOPER ©
13 EN. Towe Bi TOEATION Ta SiREET aN OME
ESE
Gees
yf
5G
ae
Oe:
Se ReROENGE ETE [He CoN
CHARLOTTE =| PORT, CHARLOTTE. 21495 ELDRED AVE.
ra ee | a SLEPT OA,
os See Regan oe, Se | Been
2 B3952 fey Et WHITE we i
iT FARR 5 Wa Wa a TARAS RAGE Po tt Maden Sewer)
RL
‘FRANKLIN’ SIMON PEARL WOLTNSKI
t TBS WANG AOETS Sol and Tatton Raa Fron CaF © Hw, Se. Zo COT
NE.
SARAH SIMON : 21495. ELDREDVAVE.',PORT CHARLOTTE, FL. 33952
FTL GSE ae ee veer | OEATONT he OA
‘NO
Pia OCOD OF OBOE
pene —onmeen Cprmensns | RESTLAWN MEMORIAL’ GARDENS PORT CHARLOTTE, FLOR!
TER RET ARTA, SORTCEENEEEOR TERRE
Reman gaan Weta
“Ie HAE AND AGOTEST OF UTTN
: (/KAYS-PONGER/ROYAL PALM FUNERAL HOME
¥E4070 "2405 HARBOR BLVD., PORT CHARLOTTE,
Fis Gate Donn o earonanan tio naigunen Sor ON GERUTTH
[ag oe eis ctl ee a
BS (signature end te : "
ie, is onic BEND io
ree we | oP ue
CEE CK EE ae ke) mest
PORT. CHARLOTTE, FL. 33952
i SuaREGSTIAR ~ SONATUTE HOOT Tas ig RETR S FPO
x
RewLl Dicart,
sae Te ae a eg, ch ae a arisen ale, oc ra
a ETRE
ce
PART Eo na tatan rat Camas coed a oe DB
= PARI aor Uta ane cme on aur hoe
BESS Aue Ceeiphalpctly
a &
ee
IS
Se
ES me
TTDI TSHR WAS UNSATISFACTORY FOR
SoA GREG BEPRO DUCTION AT THE TIME
~ OF IMAGIN “
Tia GASATALIORSY | 278 WERE AUTOPSY FewwaiGs
Rinvonutor ISe0 10 COUNLETE CAUSE
per Na) OF DEATH? (vere)
NO
Sa BOSE CRATES PART To ENTER CONDITION FGA WT WAS PED OHIED
=a
7
TRE
Prcanany ne oat
‘Suoktese ves HO
mona [ae ee
(Mone oar eo” |.
z
Z
AN
mx
Giz sscunir seers bo nor seceer arcu Yes
Preview
DAK:ik IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 97-605 20™ JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO. 00-120 CA (00-1544 CA - consolidated) into main case) SALLY SIMON, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Simon, Plaintiff, vs. MARK ASPERILLA, M.D., MARK ASPERILLA, M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, DALE GREENBERG, M.D., RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., LEVY BAKER CONSTINE & GREENBERG, M.D. P.A., a Florida corporation, SAMUEL ESTEPA, M.D., PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIANS, INC., a Florida corpora- tion, NASIR KHALIDI, M.D., NASIR KHALIDI, M.D., & SAKINA KHALIDI, M.D., P.A., a Florida corporation, and CONRAD EPPING KOERPER, M.D., COLEMAN & CASTELLON, M.D., P.A., a/k/a CHARLOTTE RADIOLOGY GROUP, and BON SECOURS- ST. JOSEPH HOSPITAL, a Florida corporation, Defendants. / RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE OF DEFENDANT, COLEMAN & CASTELLON, M.D., P.A. IMAGED 7 Charlotte County Clerk C1237375 Date : 01/23/04 - 14:16:02 id: 14 Case#: 00000120CA Hill 0008 IAN KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7000 SW 97" AVE., #210, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791Simon v. Asperilla, M.D., etal., Case No. 00-120-CA. COMES NOW, the Plaintiff, SALLY SIMON, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Simon, by and through her undersigned attorney, and in response to the Request To Produce propounded to said party by Defendant, COLEMAN & CASTELLON, M.D., P.A., on October 30, 2000, states as follows: 41. Response to Request No. 1, previously forwarded on or about December 6, 2000, at the time of responding to Request to Produce of Defendant, Bon-Secours. 2. Response to Request No. 2, none. 3. Response to Request No. 3, photographs in Plaintiff's possession are available for inspection at a mutually convenient date and time. 4. Response to Request No. 4, none other than any presuit responses that may have been received by Plaintiffs counsel, copies of which would certainly be in the possession of defense counsel. 5. Response to Request No. 5, objection, none as to the Plaintiff, and objection, work product, if there are any notes concerning any oral conversations that any person in the employ of Plaintiffs counsel may have had with any agent, servant and/or employee of this Defendant. 6. Response to Request No. 6, see response to No. 3 above. 7. Response to Request No. 7, see response to No. 1 above. 8. Response to Request No. 8, see response to No. 1 above. 9. Response to Request No. 9, attached. 10. Response to Request No. 10, attached. KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7000 SW 97" AVE., #210, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791Simon v. Asperilla, M.D., etal., Case No. 00-120-CA 11. | Response to Request No. 11, none. | HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing, together with copies of requested documentation, were mailed this 18 day of January, 2001, to: CLIFFORDL. SOMERS, ESQ., BARR MURMAN TONELLI SLOTHER & SLEET, Attorneys for Defendant, Coleman 7 Castellon, M.D., P.A., 201 E. Kennedy Blvd., #1750, Tampa, FL 33602; and true and correct copies of the foregoing Response were furnished to all counsel listed on attached certificate of service. KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A. Attorneys for Plaintiff 7000 S.W. 97th Avenue, Suite 210 Miami, FL 33173 305 595-6791 - Dade 305 595-5400 - Fascimile i DENNIS A. KOLTUN Fla. Bar No. 163040 KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A., ATTORNEYS AT LAW, 7000 SW 97" AVE., #210, MIAMI, FL 33173 (305) 595-6791CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE RE: SIMON V. ASPERILLA, M.D., ETAL. - CASE NO. 00-120 CA pF HEREBY CERTIFY that true and correct copies of the foregoing were mailed this day of January, 2001, to: THOMAS A. CULMO, ESQ. Culmo & Culmo, P.A. Co-Counsel for Plaintiff 2400 South Dixie Highway, #100 Miami, FL 33133 KIMBERLY J. LEE, ESQ. Wicker, Smith, Tutan, O'Hara, McCoy, Graham & Ford, P.A. Attorneys for Defs, Dr. Khalidi P.O. Box 2152 100 North Tampa Street, #3650 Tampa, FL 33601-2152 BENITO H. DIAZ, ESQ. Diaz & Morel-Saruski Attorneys for Defs., Samuel Estepa, MD & Primary Care Phys. Organization 2912 Douglas Road Coral Gables, FL 33134 LYNN H. GROSECLOSE, ESQ. Thompson Goadis Thompson Groseclose & Richardson, P.A. Attorneys for Defs., Asperilla, MD 100 Wallace Avenue, #240 Sarasota, FL 34237 CLIFFORD L. SOMERS, ESQ. Barr Murman & Tonelli, P.A. Attorneys for Defendant., Coleman and Castellon, P.A. 201 East Kennedy Blvd., #1750 & 2000 Tampa, FL 33602 CRAIG R. STEVENS, ESQ. George, Hart z, Lundeen & Fulmer Attorneys for Defs Greenberg, Constine, & Levy, Baker, Constine & Greenberg 2000 Main Street, #402 Fort Myers, FL 33901 RAYMOND REISER, ESQ. REISER & ALLISON, P.A. Attorneys for Defendant., Koerper 1 Southeast Third Avenue, #1860 Miami, FL 33131 KELLY JO SMITH, ESQ. Hahn, Morgan & Lamb, P.A. Attorneys for Defendant., Bon Secours 2701 N. Rocky Point Drive, #410 Tampa, FL 33607-5917 KOLTUN & LAZAR, P.A. Attorneys for Plaintiff 7101 S.W. 102 Avenue Miami, FL 33173 305 595-6791 - Dade 305 595-5400 - Facsimile Waris fe DENNIS A. KOLTUN FBN: 163040RESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 9 Marriage CertificateWARE HE APPLICATION NO _ FLORIDA STATE FILE NO. a 7 ern TUB TT gi soe Mac we ot a MICHBEL GARY SIMON - PERSONAL 161 ererBbave. ON Sit. tat areas “ yd Port Charlotte Charlotte Florida 33952 | 525-42 i 39 5 = 7 pepcete wetars TOWWTO GH wr nov suse want ezauray DATA | FIC AS MASH ERUED RY avec eat SRE SERA eae ze! divorce _sonce ua asncueens 12-8-80 N.Y. g kine v vitiss ioe tot, T Bower name e ilatcr, 3 Rice : toa : Fevane | 3 | eS PERSO _COOPER i i Gane. te) = Jes Evade ave (osm Fae} Va pate oF are TERE PERSONA: | me ! etexe . : ' CP inate - x x: Z 395 {11-27-47 33 2 FON OF TO ath TF @AEVIGUSEY MARRIED _-. 1 FATE 4 Bin SNOT NUR a waMeCGuNTeY pata | OD, maariace APRS ENDED SV ieecns ouazm PAB DATE LAS MAMATE NOE it sy Th GWOREE BR AKU LM ENT HL . pel. —_———| 6 " x = J GYR ANG ESCE AND BF s $ | a AFFIDAVIT ae OF FEMALE! AND MALE | ae Cente ae The MIAIR ASE ACCT ter Sate 3c eaaye 37 $4 BES IN OP EEA, Hp &. CHEATD BY FELONY ro | ae eA see7 7 Minti Solomon Agin © Rabbi, Temple Beth-El HL OREBO.BOx OTD ot MARRY 1 ey Pewee fy count syek Le Cape Corai,FL This licensa valid uniess seal ot Clerk, AUDIT . cuit sr County Court, appears thereon. UDIT CONTROL NO. t i . Ceeteg ssat Maz, A * 4p," 0. AL “eeogsasd tltRESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 10 Death CertificateOFFICE of VITAL STATISTICS CERTIFIED COPY i We Gee CERTIFICATE OF OEATH "FLORIDA : ~7 Tage TTT TH MICHAEL Al = : ® MA) GEREN BRE BF GAIT oa ap = AUGUST 21, 1998 : “Bb Tea BE a Bac or ea won Om wo T inte ace fg Sh 2g COM, MAY, 25,1942 BROOKLYN): NEW YORK BF DEN a Be fs OT ; HOSPINAL X. eqmuant! = CROAoineN’ —"DOR. Ahm regis REE omnes ford or Rone SawGRIrt “MEMORIAL HOSPITAL — : o EEE VEU OCVPAIO OF BURMERSANOHISTIN i ‘QUNER/OPERATOR MARINE SERVICES ED. SARAH COOPER © 13 EN. Towe Bi TOEATION Ta SiREET aN OME ESE Gees yf 5G ae Oe: Se ReROENGE ETE [He CoN CHARLOTTE =| PORT, CHARLOTTE. 21495 ELDRED AVE. ra ee | a SLEPT OA, os See Regan oe, Se | Been 2 B3952 fey Et WHITE we i iT FARR 5 Wa Wa a TARAS RAGE Po tt Maden Sewer) RL ‘FRANKLIN’ SIMON PEARL WOLTNSKI t TBS WANG AOETS Sol and Tatton Raa Fron CaF © Hw, Se. Zo COT NE. SARAH SIMON : 21495. ELDREDVAVE.',PORT CHARLOTTE, FL. 33952 FTL GSE ae ee veer | OEATONT he OA ‘NO Pia OCOD OF OBOE pene —onmeen Cprmensns | RESTLAWN MEMORIAL’ GARDENS PORT CHARLOTTE, FLOR! TER RET ARTA, SORTCEENEEEOR TERRE Reman gaan Weta “Ie HAE AND AGOTEST OF UTTN : (/KAYS-PONGER/ROYAL PALM FUNERAL HOME ¥E4070 "2405 HARBOR BLVD., PORT CHARLOTTE, Fis Gate Donn o earonanan tio naigunen Sor ON GERUTTH [ag oe eis ctl ee a BS (signature end te : " ie, is onic BEND io ree we | oP ue CEE CK EE ae ke) mest PORT. CHARLOTTE, FL. 33952 i SuaREGSTIAR ~ SONATUTE HOOT Tas ig RETR S FPO x RewLl Dicart, sae Te ae a eg, ch ae a arisen ale, oc ra a ETRE ce PART Eo na tatan rat Camas coed a oe DB = PARI aor Uta ane cme on aur hoe BESS Aue Ceeiphalpctly a & ee IS Se ES me TTDI TSHR WAS UNSATISFACTORY FOR SoA GREG BEPRO DUCTION AT THE TIME ~ OF IMAGIN “ Tia GASATALIORSY | 278 WERE AUTOPSY FewwaiGs Rinvonutor ISe0 10 COUNLETE CAUSE per Na) OF DEATH? (vere) NO Sa BOSE CRATES PART To ENTER CONDITION FGA WT WAS PED OHIED =a 7 TRE Prcanany ne oat ‘Suoktese ves HO mona [ae ee (Mone oar eo” |. z Z AN mx Giz sscunir seers bo nor seceer arcu Yes