Preview
..IN HE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, INA AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA _
IVIL ACTION
SALLY SIMON, as Personal ve
of the Estate of MICHAEL SI
Plaintiff,
vs. Case No. 00-120 CA
P.A., a Florida ALE GREENBERG, i Mc D.
RONALD
CONSTINE,
GREENBERG M.D. PA. a Florida G ion,
EL ESTEPA, M.D. Reise acne
NC a tied ion, NASIR KHALIDI M.D.,
NASIR KNALIDTS (A KHALIDI, M P.A,,
a Florida Corporation, CONRAD EPPING KOERPER, M.D.,
COLEMAN & CASTELLON, M.D. P.A,, alkia CHARLOTTE
RADIOLOGY GROUP, and BON SECOURS-S
HOSPITAL, a Florida Corporation,
Defendants. '
IStUWY €1 Soy lone
DEFENDANT RONALD CONSTINE, M.D.’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., by and through his undersigned counsel and
pursuant to F.R.Civ.P. 1.510 moves this Court for a Summary Judgment in his favor and
against the Plaintiff on the grounds that there is no material issue of fact and the pleadings,
depositions, interrogatories, and other matters of record including but not fimited to the
attached affidavit of medical expert witness Georges Boutin, M.D. show that the Defendant
RONALD CONSTINE, M.D. is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law on all issues and/or
any claims arising in any way out of the contact MICHAEL SIMON had with Defendant
RONALD CONSTINE, M.D.
As specific grounds for this Motion, this Defendant would show that there is
insufficient evidence that a deviation from the standard of care occurred during MICHAEL
SIMON’s contact with Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., or that Defendant RONALD
CONSTINE, M.D. caused medical injury to MICHAEL SIMON.
|
!
|
Charlotte County Clerk :
: 1281748 Date 4/16/01 - 40:15:16 id: 902 ree?
) Casei#. 00000120CA itil Oo
“Tao-» WHEREFORE, Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D. respectfully requests this
Honorable Court to enter an Order granting summary judgment in his favor and against
Plaintiff.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
| HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing has
been furnished by U. S. Mail to Thomas A. Culmo, P.A., Grove Professional Building, 2950
S.W. 27" Avenue, Suite 100, Miami, FL 33133; Dennis A. Koltun, P.A., 7101 S.W. 102"
Avenue, Miami, FL 33173; John C. Hamilton, Esq., WICKER, SMITH, TUTAN, O'HARA,
McCOY, GRAHAM, & FORD P.A., Attorneys for Defendant Dr. Khalidi, P.O. Box 2152,
Tampa, FL 33601-2152; Benito H. Diaz, Esq., DIAZ & MOREL-SARSKI, Attorneys for
Defendants Samue! Estepa, MD and Primary Care Phys. Organization, 2912 Douglas Rd.,
Coral Gables, FL 33134; Lynn H. Groseclose, Esq., THOMPSON GOODIS THOMPSON,
GROSECLOSE & RCHARDSON, P.A., Attorneys for Defendant Asperilla, M.D.,Post Office
Box 730, Bradenton, FL 34206; Raymond A. Reiser, Esq., RAYMOND A. REISER &
ASSOCIATES, Attorneys for Conrad Koerper, M.D., One Southeast Third Avenue, Suntrust
Intel Center, Suite 1860, Miami, FL 33131;Eugene Smith, Esq., HENDERSON, FRANKLIN,
STARNES & HOLT, P.A., Attorneys for Defendant St. Joseph's Hospital, P.O. Box 280, Fort
Myers, FL 33902; Clifford L. Somers, Esq., BARR, MURMAN & TONELLI, P.A., Attorneys
for Coleman & Castellon, M.D., P.A., 201 East Kennedy Bivd., #1750, Tampa, FL 33602
this_[ O Gay of April, 2001. GEORGE, HARTZ, LUNDEEN FULMER,
JOHNSTONE, KING & STEVENS
Atiomays for Defendants DALE GREENBERG,
M._D., D. RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., and LEVY,
BAKER, CONSTINE & GREENBERG, PA.
2000 Main Street, Suite 402
For My Myers, Florida 33901
Crai aig R. Stevens
Fla. Bar No.: 06149
2
Preview
..IN HE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, INA AND FOR CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA _ IVIL ACTION SALLY SIMON, as Personal ve of the Estate of MICHAEL SI Plaintiff, vs. Case No. 00-120 CA P.A., a Florida ALE GREENBERG, i Mc D. RONALD CONSTINE, GREENBERG M.D. PA. a Florida G ion, EL ESTEPA, M.D. Reise acne NC a tied ion, NASIR KHALIDI M.D., NASIR KNALIDTS (A KHALIDI, M P.A,, a Florida Corporation, CONRAD EPPING KOERPER, M.D., COLEMAN & CASTELLON, M.D. P.A,, alkia CHARLOTTE RADIOLOGY GROUP, and BON SECOURS-S HOSPITAL, a Florida Corporation, Defendants. ' IStUWY €1 Soy lone DEFENDANT RONALD CONSTINE, M.D.’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., by and through his undersigned counsel and pursuant to F.R.Civ.P. 1.510 moves this Court for a Summary Judgment in his favor and against the Plaintiff on the grounds that there is no material issue of fact and the pleadings, depositions, interrogatories, and other matters of record including but not fimited to the attached affidavit of medical expert witness Georges Boutin, M.D. show that the Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D. is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law on all issues and/or any claims arising in any way out of the contact MICHAEL SIMON had with Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D. As specific grounds for this Motion, this Defendant would show that there is insufficient evidence that a deviation from the standard of care occurred during MICHAEL SIMON’s contact with Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., or that Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D. caused medical injury to MICHAEL SIMON. | ! | Charlotte County Clerk : : 1281748 Date 4/16/01 - 40:15:16 id: 902 ree? ) Casei#. 00000120CA itil Oo “Tao-» WHEREFORE, Defendant RONALD CONSTINE, M.D. respectfully requests this Honorable Court to enter an Order granting summary judgment in his favor and against Plaintiff. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE | HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing has been furnished by U. S. Mail to Thomas A. Culmo, P.A., Grove Professional Building, 2950 S.W. 27" Avenue, Suite 100, Miami, FL 33133; Dennis A. Koltun, P.A., 7101 S.W. 102" Avenue, Miami, FL 33173; John C. Hamilton, Esq., WICKER, SMITH, TUTAN, O'HARA, McCOY, GRAHAM, & FORD P.A., Attorneys for Defendant Dr. Khalidi, P.O. Box 2152, Tampa, FL 33601-2152; Benito H. Diaz, Esq., DIAZ & MOREL-SARSKI, Attorneys for Defendants Samue! Estepa, MD and Primary Care Phys. Organization, 2912 Douglas Rd., Coral Gables, FL 33134; Lynn H. Groseclose, Esq., THOMPSON GOODIS THOMPSON, GROSECLOSE & RCHARDSON, P.A., Attorneys for Defendant Asperilla, M.D.,Post Office Box 730, Bradenton, FL 34206; Raymond A. Reiser, Esq., RAYMOND A. REISER & ASSOCIATES, Attorneys for Conrad Koerper, M.D., One Southeast Third Avenue, Suntrust Intel Center, Suite 1860, Miami, FL 33131;Eugene Smith, Esq., HENDERSON, FRANKLIN, STARNES & HOLT, P.A., Attorneys for Defendant St. Joseph's Hospital, P.O. Box 280, Fort Myers, FL 33902; Clifford L. Somers, Esq., BARR, MURMAN & TONELLI, P.A., Attorneys for Coleman & Castellon, M.D., P.A., 201 East Kennedy Bivd., #1750, Tampa, FL 33602 this_[ O Gay of April, 2001. GEORGE, HARTZ, LUNDEEN FULMER, JOHNSTONE, KING & STEVENS Atiomays for Defendants DALE GREENBERG, M._D., D. RONALD CONSTINE, M.D., and LEVY, BAKER, CONSTINE & GREENBERG, PA. 2000 Main Street, Suite 402 For My Myers, Florida 33901 Crai aig R. Stevens Fla. Bar No.: 06149 2